Kamilah Aisha Moon, Salman Rushdie, and an Archive of Love

Towards the end of The Flower Bearers, we see Rachel Eliza Griffiths visit the papers of Lucille Clifton and Alice Walker at Emory University and the papers of Toni Cade Bambara and Audre Lorde at Spelman College. We see her hands shake over Clifton’s spirit writing, carefully lift the first draft of Bambara’s The Salt Eaters out of a folder, and trace Lorde’s journals.

These visits aren’t research trips, and on this point, Griffiths does not want to be mistaken: “I’m not a scholar. I’m not an academic. I’m a madwoman.” Though the book holds a massive, exquisite and rigorous set of citations, the library trips are the completion of a journey she meant to take with her dear, deceased friend and chosen sister Kamilah Aisha Moon.

The Flower Bearers is born out of two close and tragic encounters in Griffiths’ life—the sudden death of Moon on her wedding day and the nearly-fatal attack on her husband, Salman Rushdie, which happened a few months later. It is a propulsive archive of love, loss, and reparation in lineage and sisterhood with those writers whom Griffiths and Moon aligned themselves.

The book landed on me like a sense memory. I met Griffiths and Moon twenty years ago at a writing conference where Griffiths and I discovered we lived on the exact same street in NYC. The friendship might have been born out of proximity but became a profound part of my twenties, for to know Griffiths and Moon, Rachel Eliza and Aisha, was to know and be part of a sisterhood in letters, to understand that even the smallest of small talk resides, as Griffiths puts it, “somewhere inside the complex language of Black womanhood.” 

I knew the book would mean something special to me but I did not realize I’d read it in two days. Grief is a sneaky thing and this book helped me bear its beauty.

Over Zoom, Griffiths and I talked as madwomen do.


Nina Sharma: When I was preparing for this interview I suddenly felt inhibited, shy to share the joy of remembering Aisha through this book. Could you speak about how it feels to share this friendship with the world?

Rachel Eliza Griffiths: While this book was very difficult, the reason why the grief and the trauma of the loss feels so difficult is because the love was, and is, so massive.

It often happens with loss—the first part of your grief is the closest thing to you, their physical death. But, if you can, go back before that part. It takes time and concentration, which you don’t have space for in the beginning. For me, it was like diving into water, getting deeper beneath the surface. You can look up and barely see where you came from. But you feel that the love between you and that person just keeps going.

NS: There’s a journey of getting past the breakers to that ocean of love.

REG: Yes. One of the ways that I got through the breakers was finally being curious about my grief. I’m thinking now of the promise that Aisha and I had made to visit the archives of our literary foremothers, to do that pilgrimage together. So, after Aisha’s passing, rather than feel like, “Well, I’m not gonna do that now,” I thought, no, now I must do it because I didn’t have anything else to hold on to. I was drowning.

Grief can often feel very passive, like being swept along, especially in the beginning. There’s no control. Maybe because I’m looking at the ocean right now as you and I speak, I remember feeling like I was locked inside a riptide. At some point, I began to think about what I could do, in terms of an action. I began with some questions. What did Aisha and I love? What did we care about? What mattered to us? Different things started to sprout and to grow from that.

NS: Realizing your grief is on a different timeline than others is such a real and unsung part of grieving. I think this is especially true with someone like Aisha. So many people feel an intimate connection with her. Thinking about your journey to owning your timeline, when did you feel ready to write about this? Was that even something you had the luxury of thinking about, being “ready” to write?

REG: I don’t think there was a moment when I felt like I was ready to write. My writing was an effect of the panic that I’d start to forget our memories and their textures of our relationship. Because that invariably happens to some extent.

Grief can often feel very passive. I remember feeling like I was locked inside a riptide.

The memoir really began with a lot of questions. Not even, why did this happen? That’s like a “breaker” question. You have to get far beyond that to something more like, how did this love begin? How will it go on? How will I survive?

There’s a clip where Toni Morrison talks about not surviving whole. Something happens to you, but you don’t survive whole. What you can do is go forward with a kind of elegance. Elegance and a deliberate energy about not surviving whole. Morrison doesn’t say that means you’re wounded or less, but I was so deeply wounded. I once had a muscle, many poets do, where poets are asked to stand and hold the line of humanity in the face of loss, injustice, violence, grief, war, fear, and so on. In this instance, which was so personal, I couldn’t hold anything.

NS: Thinking about where the love begins brings me to you and Aisha coming up as writers together. While you and Aisha met in an MFA program, you both sought and found an enduring writing life that was not defined by the program. I love the scenes of your early years in New York together. Can you talk about this part of your sisterhood?

REG: Prior to Sarah Lawrence, I was much more of a loner. When I met Aisha, there was this joy of having my first adult Black girlfriend sister, that kind of joy of discovering someone who feels like kin, that you’re not alone. Aisha and I were deeply committed and deeply serious about developing ourselves as poets. It wasn’t just the work on the page. Poetry is a way of living. You’re expanding. Everything’s at stake. It’s not just sitting down at the MFA table. There’s not just one table.

NS: I remember spending time with you and Aisha in those years in West Village, dancing. Maybe the little sister in me was activated, but it always felt like we were doing something important, like something really important was happening.

REG: Suddenly, I remember the image of James Baldwin dancing with Lorraine Hansbury in somebody’s living room. The joy! Or the photograph of Toni Morrison’s glowing smile as she’s dancing with her arms up in the sky at a party. I love that photograph of Amiri Baraka with Maya Angelou at the Schomburg. They’re dancing on the sacred site of Langston Hughes’ ashes, you know?

Aisha and I could explore all these different spaces and know the functions of those spaces and where they overlapped. I remember nights where you could hear a pin drop sometimes at Bar Thirteen during a Patricia Smith reading. And then other times when you were encouraged to holler, to participate in roll call. All of these spaces were necessary. You could go to a KGB Bar reading, that’s a certain kind of environment. You could go to Louder Arts at Bar Thirteen. You could go to Cornelia Street Cafe, which no longer exists, and that’s a different kind of environment. We would go to all of them.

There were years where the pace of life in New York was heartbreaking. We had to hustle. We were teaching classes from 8 am to evening. We’d call each other, “I’m on the bus,” “I’m getting on the train,” “I’ve got to go to office hours,” “I haven’t gotten a moment to eat yet today.” It was work. The labor could wear you down. To defy the labor, to resist feeling beat down, we’d have to find the party. For us, the best part of the party was the music.

NS: Let’s talk about the music. “Love language” is a corny phrase but anyone who knows Aisha knows music was her love language. It’s there in your “meet-cute” where, grabbing a drink at a campus bar, you and Aisha stitch together life histories in jukebox songs. You write, “Music, good music, was our language.” Can you talk about the place of music in your relationship?

REG: I remember a time when there would be such shyness and risk in sharing your playlist with another person. It was like inviting them into your brain, into your whole being.

Poetry is a way of living. You’re expanding. Everything’s at stake.

The day that I met Aisha, we were immediately offering each other mixtapes. Throughout our friendship, we’d send each other music at all times. Here’s a praise song; here’s a song for the morning; here’s your birthday song; here’s an IDGAF anthem; here’s an I know you’ve had a really rough week song. Here’s a Deep Breath song. Here’s a song to hold you up in joy.

Sometimes, you can get into the patterns or rhythms of knowing someone and their tastes. But with Aisha, you could get really surprised by what she might play. 

NS: Oh my god, yes. I have that memory with Aisha—talking about The Human League together.

REG: Aisha loved The Human League, right? And she was from Nashville, so the blues and country too. Aisha could go in all directions with music. Her musical intelligence is in all her poems. It was in her physical voice. It’s also how she often held a vibrational space with people. Aisha could listen to people, listen to their songs, and then offer almost like this expanded version of their song. The extended album cut. She’d add in those things that you were trying to ask or think about or feel out. Aisha put in extra lines for you. And you’d think, oh yeah, that’s what I was missing or oh yeah, you filled the song in for me with what I needed, thank you. It was so beautiful.

NS: I want to sit with that for a minute—the vibrational space that she held, that your friendship held. I want to think about that in relation to the ongoing health conversation you had together. Can you speak to what it meant to create this space? 

REG: We really talked about everything. How could we not talk about our bodies particularly as Black women? For example, Lucille Clifton’s work has so much to do with her body, and the bodies of her beloveds—her mother, her daughters, her children, and Black people. Alice Walker, Toni Morrison, and Gayle Jones were all writers who wrote of Black women’s bodies in ways we admired. Sonia Sanchez continues to center her body and its dignity. 

Sometimes, while writing, you can almost feel like you’re out of your body because of your mind, your spirit. You’re in this other space. But it’s your body through which you’re receiving language, stories, testaments, tears, laughter, all of it. The entire human collective is in you in that instant.

I remember how Aisha loved talking about her hair and getting her haircuts, curling her hair, deep conditioning her hair, which was beautiful. I miss her hair. It was such a part of her. We were both into tending our eyebrows. You know, things with women are not just a simple conversation.

NS: In this book you come out as being diagnosed with Dissociative Identity Disorder, which is as much an in-the-body as it is an out-of-body experience. Do you think that dissociative identity disorder puts you in touch with your body in ways that you might otherwise not be?

REG: When I was younger, I didn’t have much education about mental health. I just had panic, anxiety, so much shame. I didn’t even hear about the term, “Dissociative Identity Disorder,” until my late twenties. Seeing how DID is often portrayed is really devastating to me. The older language for it orbits multiple personality and horror movie narratives, like Jekyll and Hyde. That’s not an accurate representation. I’ve rarely seen any accurate representations. Even people in psychotherapy don’t really have a standardized language for it and have different opinions about how DID works.

I started Sarah Lawrence in my 20s barely a few months after a very severe suicide attempt where I was in a psych ward. Mental health is extraordinarily important to me. It’s such a private, intimate thing yet it affects every behavior, it affects everything, and I’ll always be interested in it because I have to maintain an active daily practice that pays attention to my inner life beyond writing and art. 

NS: It seems like you and Aisha created a space where your health histories became legible. It makes me realize that this book, as much as it’s about grief, and it’s extensively and beautifully about grief, is about the choice to live. I think that you and Aisha together made a choice to live, from the beginning. And that choice flows through the book.

REG: Yes. I think coming from where I was coming, arriving at Sarah Lawrence and just needing to heal—in some way, the last thing I should’ve been doing after being hospitalized was putting myself in a graduate program for creative writing. But it was the best thing to do. When I met Aisha, I felt a new hope in her presence. We wanted to live fully. I feel that way now, wanting to live fully. I believe Aisha still lives now in the ways that so many of us continue to read her poetry and share our memories of our times with her.

NS: This book is both Aisha’s passing and Salman’s attack, that compoundedness of trauma. The way you and Salman care for each other is really special. I was struck by that moment in the book when you say that you and Salman, against your will, realize you’re new people in a new life, a second act becomes a third or fourth. What did meeting each other anew teach you?

REG: When I met Salman, I was at a crossroads in my life. It was in the wake of my mother’s death. I was forced to think about who I was at that moment, aware that my identity was suddenly detached from what I thought I’d been before in roles as a daughter, sister, wife. 

It’s very hard to have a book that you write against your will.

Our connection was one of the things that immediately made sense to me. I felt like I was home. I thought, Oh, I don’t have to explain. I don’t have to defend. I don’t have to convince. That was a new, almost uncomfortable feeling because I was used to everything being difficult and overthinking. Suddenly, it was just like, “You’re a grown woman, what do you want?” I wanted a life with this person. It was clear to me.

I also want to go back to the two events occurring with Aisha and with Salman that form this book. It’s very hard to have a book that you write against your will. A former version of me would’ve tried to keep writing more poems, or another novel, or concentrate on visual art and not tell anyone how much I love these two people, not tell anyone how vulnerable I was as a child, or what it’d been like as a young writer going through different experiences and hardships.

Both Aisha and Salman will always be in my work, not necessarily explicitly, and not because of the grief and the trauma. It’s about the love that I hold and carry from each of these individuals.

NS: I always say, “I’m bad at grief,” even though that doesn’t make much sense. Sudden death is uniquely hard to grieve. You write at one point “I don’t need to memorize Aisha’s dying . . . I need to memorize how fearlessly Aisha shone.” I was wondering what advice you have for others who have incomplete endings?

REG: I think most people are bad at grief, right? It’s such an intimate space. And there’s nothing identical in the grieving experience. It’s so surreal and distinct, relative to the loss. When you experience ambiguous loss, you’ll spiral out to sea or space. You must figure out how to stop breathing into what you can’t know. You must breathe into what you do know, which is love. Because love is what is going to rescue you.

I tried to intellectualize my experiences but I learned that for me, I needed to focus on caring for my body. For example, I have a regular practice of immersing myself in sound baths. Vibrations in that environment will often do more for my brain fog than a 200 page book. Reading a book involves a cognitive engagement while the sound bath is doing something deeper that I can’t overthink. I have to surrender and open my body to it.

NS: It’s funny that you say that because we’re writers, we are word people. I think the writing actually comes from that sonic vibrational space, you know? This book really feels like you share a vibrational energy with us.

REG: I could never write this book now. For me, it’s still astonishing that I wrote it at all. I don’t know what I’ll do next, but I know that I gave everything to The Flower Bearers.

Hopefully the book gives its gifts to others. Because I know that there are others grieving and coping with trauma and identity. In a way, this book has already helped me keep going. It is enough. That’s something too, showing up for past selves and past lives. It’s enough. I miss Aisha. I want to call her. I want to talk to her. But it’s enough, what I had for seventeen years. It’s enough.

7 Novels About Women Who Lose the Plot

I love books about women who go off the rails. They can be comic or tragic. Either way there’s something serious underfoot. When a woman loses the plot, she has a good reason. She signed a deal and wants to renege. She may suddenly have some serious second thoughts about her entire life. There are many ways to say it, but it basically comes down to this: A woman can no longer abide. The center will not hold.

In my novel The Hitch, a woman looks after her six-year-old nephew for a week. She’s a secular, atheist Jew with an allergy to anything numinous. So when her nephew announces he’s been possessed by the soul of a recently deceased corgi, her world implodes. Compressed into a single, frantic week, the book accelerates the shift in her worldview from the material to the spiritual. But my main goal was to upset all the premises by which she organized her rational world. That’s what interests me—the shattering of the container in which the protagonist lives. 

In the books below, the inciting incidents are familiar enough: a friend’s death, a husband’s betrayal, a move away from home. But the protagonists react in extremes. They lose their grip and things accelerate at an alarming pace. In life, one often moves slowly and clumsily towards a change of mind. These novels celebrate reckless speed, dizzying intensity, audacious rudeness, and the abandonment of social norms. They invite you to consider: What if I lost control? 

Hangsaman by Shirley Jackson

First published in 1951, Hangsaman is the second, wonderfully strange novel by the American writer Shirley Jackson. Hangsaman begins with a teenage girl living at home with her hilariously awful family. “Natalie Waite, who was seventeen years old but who felt that she had been truly conscious only since she was about fifteen, lived in an odd corner of a world of sound and sight past the daily voices of her father and mother and their incomprehensible actions.” Her father is a pretentious domineering blowhard; her mother is unhappy and weak. Maybe when Natalie goes off to college, she’ll feel a bit better. Maybe she’ll like a professor, make a friend, join a club, give up conversing with an imaginary detective. Instead, Natalie leaves home and descends into new depths of alienation and self-torment. Her psychic collapse leaves little doubt as to how Jackson felt about the gender politics of higher education. And I thought I had a scary freshman year!  

Is Mother Dead by Vigdis Hjorth, translated by Charlotte Barslund

Er mor død (translated from Norwegian to English by Charlotte Barslund) tells the story of Johanna, a recently widowed artist, long estranged from her parents and sister, who returns to Oslo for a retrospective exhibit. One night, a little bit drunk, she calls her elderly mother on the phone, but her mother hangs up as soon as she hears her daughter’s voice. Johanna becomes obsessed by the rejection and spins out, wracked by anxiety, longing, fury, mistrust, and shame. One minute she’s trying to remember what her mother said to her before Johanna left Norway, the next she’s stealing her mother’s garbage and stalking the woman as she visits her husband’s grave. Is Mother Dead is the book I recommend people read for Mother’s Day, when the rest of the world grows saccharine about mother-daughter bonds. Part thriller, part meditation, it is strong, sickening, and original. 

The Dangerous Husband by Jane Shapiro

The narrator of this perfect and criminally underrated novel has no name. The man she meets at a Manhattan dinner party is called Dennis. Being forty, they fall in love promptly, marry hastily, spend an appropriate amount of time eating expensive cheese and gazing at each other with “that lover’s mix of tenderness, gratitude, suppressed anxiety, and lust.” Then she realizes he has flaws. Dennis is weirdly clumsy. Accident-prone. Frankly, a menace. As the disasters pile up (broken bones as well as objects), marriage loses its allure. “It was turning out that my husband’s dishevelment was incomparable, potent, ramifying. It could destroy whole little worlds.” Unless she destroys him first. Determined to save herself, the newlywed hires a hit man to kill her husband. The Dangerous Husband shapes a fairy tale marriage into a screwball comedy with horror vibes, in luminous, pitch-perfect prose.

She-Devil in the Mirror by Horacio Castellanos Moya, translated by Katherine Silver

In Katherine Silver’s translation of La diabla en el espejo, Laura Riveria is rich, shallow, gossipy, and totally stunned when her friend Olga Maria is gunned down in her home. “How could such a tragedy have happened, my dear? I just spent the whole morning with Olga Maria at her boutique at the Villa Españolas Mall, she had to check on a special order. I still can’t believe it; it’s like a nightmare.” This is not the voice of Sherlock Holmes, Hercule Poirot, or Jules Maigret, but Laura is determined to solve the mystery of her BFF’s murder (in between catching the latest episode of a telenovela). Chapters change location (The Wake, The Burial, The Balcony, The Clinic), but Laura is the only voice allowed to tell a story that clearly exceeds her grasp. A dazzling, dark, hilariously one-sided account of a woman playing detective in post-civil war San Salvador, unravelling her mind and possibly some truth.    

The Days of Abandonment by Elena Ferrante, translated by Ann Goldstein

Olga, 38, lives with her family in Turin. One day her husband announces he is leaving. Thinking Mario is experiencing a temporary “absence of sense,” Olga plans to wait it out—until she realizes he’s taken a lover. “Organize your defenses, preserve your wholeness, don’t let yourself break like an ornament, you’re not a knickknack, no woman is a knickknack,” Olga tells herself, but feminist theory can’t keep her intact. The Days of Abandonment is a frenzied chronicle of a woman’s descent into hell, accompanied by two small children and a sick German Shepherd. The details resist summary, but here’s a taste: When Olga bumps into Mario on the street, she throws him against a plate-glass window. “Into what world did I sink, into what world did I re-emerge? To what life am I restored? And to what purpose?” she asks. Eventually Olga ascends. A gripping, unapologetic book, shameless in the best sense.  

Revenge of the Scapegoat by Caren Beilin

One day Iris, a writing instructor, receives a package containing documents from her teenage years: a play she wrote and two letters from her father, blaming her for the family’s ruin. After complaining to her friend Ray, who is about to have top surgery, Iris swaps her mildewy house for Ray’s doddering Subaru and drives off to the countryside. Did I mention the trip is poorly planned? Iris suffers from an autoimmune disease, and the funniest parts of this funny American book are the dialogues between Iris’s aching feet, whom she has named Bouvard and Pécuchet (after two characters in an unfinished Flaubert novel). The Subaru dies, and Iris lands in a field where she is stepped on by a herd of cows, then winds up working as a cowherd for a sexy lady who probably murdered her own husband and now operates a museum that’s only open one month a year. Then the story really goes off the rails.  

The Vegetarian by Han Kang, translated by Deborah Smith

The Vegetarian (ch’aesikchuŭija, translated into English by Deborah Smith) centers on a Korean housewife who abruptly stops eating meat. Told in three sections, the novel is full of surprises, partly because it’s told from three points of view, none of which belongs to the vegetarian herself. Yeong-hye’s husband, a loveless man who views his wife as “completely unremarkable in every way,” begins the story of his recalcitrant wife, but his contribution can’t explain her motives, only document his growing fury that she resembles a “hospital patient” and no longer wears a bra or willingly provides sex.  The second part documents her brother-in-law’s erotic obsession with her, even as Yeong-hye descends into psychosis and physically wastes away. The third part turns to her sister, In-hye, a hard-working, well-organized mother who is appalled, for her own reasons, at her sister’s transformation. We’ve all read books about women suffering under patriarchy, but has any protagonist ever responded to the violence by willing herself to become a tree?

Jeanette Winterson Thinks Writer’s Block Is a Con Job

When I first discovered Jeanette Winterson, I was struck by the incredible presence of her work; not only her ability to convey the tender, insular reality of love and conflict, but by the way her prose seemed to carry its own life force. Winterson doesn’t shy away from discomfort, from the turbulent landscape of her Pentecostal upbringing and disapproving family, from the question once asked of her: “Why be happy when you could be normal” (which later became the title of Winterson’s wonderfully moving 2011 memoir). 

Winterson’s writing is visceral, embodied, and patiently political, capturing the reality of growing up queer in an environment built upon suppression. In spite—or perhaps in response—Winterson’s work transmutes an irreverent, unbridled joy, even amidst the inevitable sorrow and grief that comes with a human life. Her most recent book, One Aladdin Two Lamps, shatters and reassembles Shahrazad’s One Thousand and One Nights, asking ancient questions that feel both timeless and critically important to our contemporary world.

With forty years of writing and publishing experience under her belt, I was thrilled at the opportunity to speak with Jeanette about her routines and insights on the writing life, and all the more charmed by her passion, humor, and recognition of writing’s essential role, now more than ever.

– Lennie Roeber-Tsiongas
Editorial Intern


1. What book should everyone read growing up?

Jeanette Winterson: Everyone should read Wuthering Heights, especially before Emerald Fennell’s adaptation comes out on Valentine’s Day next year. I think she’s butchered it. So read the original, then you can watch the movie, and then you can say, Jeanette Winterson knows jack shit.

  • EL: Did you see a screening? Or is this just an inkling you have?
  • JW: I’ve been following it closely. I love the costumes—Margot Robbie in red latex does it for me—and I love adaptations, but sometimes as a writer who cares about text and language and all of that stuff, you do die inside. With a movie, you get great sets, wonderful actors; you get the story, but you don’t get the language.

2. Write alone or in community?

JW: Write by yourself. Oh, absolutely. All writing is about discomfort. It’s a lie detector that starts with yourself. If you’re always chatting to somebody else, you don’t get that discomfort and you don’t do the work of the lie detector on what you’re writing. 

  • EL: I’m inclined to agree.
  • JW: If you’re doing a script or something which starts out as collaborative, a hundred percent. I’m working on a musical at the moment, and that’s really collaborative and I love it. But that’s because it fits the form. 

3. How do you start from scratch? 

JW: You don’t do it by going into the executive suite and trying to force an idea. It’s not office work, it’s not factory work. You have to work with your unconscious, with your inner self and let ideas bubble up, let images come forward, even images without words, pictures in your mind. Follow them with grace and humility. What I see with my students is a kind of terror—they close everything down and format it way too early on. That’s what I mean about discomfort. Let the thing develop. Let it play with you. And don’t tell it what it is all the time. Wait to see.

4. Three presses you’ll read anything from?

JW: Grove Press, of course. Melville House for the little editions and the essays that they do. I love those. And in Britain, Faber and Faber.

5. Hardcover, paperback, or e-reader?

JW: I always buy new books in hardcover if they exist like that because I can afford it. Somebody’s got to do it to support the industry and it’s a pleasure for me. I don’t want it on e-reader, not least because we all know that they can disappear your books any time they want.

  •  EL: I don’t like not knowing how many pages I have left to go.
  • JW: Oh, I don’t mind that. That’s interesting. But I still think there’s some perfect forms that haven’t been bettered. It is the progress fallacy. So an egg is a perfect form. An apple is a perfect form. You can’t better them. And for me, a book is a perfect form. It’s not waiting to be updated to an e-reader because some tech nerd who does everything on Blinkist thinks it’s a good idea.

6. If you were a novel, what novel would you be?

JW: I don’t want to be a novel because it’s too big a possibility. I might end up as a 19th century three volume novel, and that would be upsetting because I’d be too long, or I might end up as post-structuralist fiction. What would I be? I think I’d rather be a poem because a poem is contained, it’s pressurized, every word counts, and it’s short. It is amazing to me and kind of glorious that poetry, which everybody thought was the ultimate outdated form, has made such a comeback because it’s short and nobody’s got any attention span anymore. Never say it’s over ‘til it’s over. 

7. Describe your ideal writing day.

JW: Oh God, listen, when you’ve been doing it for 40 years, there is no such thing anymore. And that’s kind of great. When I am working, I don’t do anything outside of it. I don’t do events, I don’t do public stuff, which I do a lot of normally. So it’s just me in the country. I get up early, really early. I used to be a night owl, but now that I’m old I’m not. Walk the dog, chop the wood, light the fire, and do a couple of hours. Above all, keep your emails off, keep your Wi-Fi off. Don’t even think about it. When I’m doing real work, I never, ever switch the Wi-fi on until I’ve done the real work. Because it’s just a tsunami of interruptions, isn’t it? You have to deliberately interrupt the interruptions.

8. Typing or longhand?

JW: Never longhand, never did. When I started out, it was a typewriter and that made you look like Kermit or any of the other Muppets. You just sit there bashing it out. I love that because it gives a distance. I’ve never been somebody who carries around a notebook and writes down my thoughts, mostly because they’re garbage. It’s when I sit down and work that good things happen.

9. What’s a piece of writing advice you never want to hear again?

JW: I don’t know. I never look at writing advice. I’m a writer. I can do it. Jesus. I’ve been doing this for 40 years. If I need advice now, you shouldn’t be talking to me.

10. What’s a piece of writing advice you think everyone needs to hear? 

JW: The main thing is turn up for work. Just make a pact with yourself on what time you can reasonably spend doing your work. Don’t do magical thinking, but when you’ve made the deal with yourself, stick to it. 

11. Realism or Surrealism?

JW: Oh, God, I hate realism. I’ve never written social realism in my life, and I never will. It’s only a partial truth about who we are. I’ve spent all of my time begging people not to get lost in the literal. Without imagination, we’re nothing. 

12. What’s your favorite comfort snack for writing? 

JW: Salted peanuts. I mean, fortunately, I also have great self-discipline, so I’m not mainlining peanuts, but I do like to have a bowl of them. Probably towards the end, when I feel that I’m in the last hour, which is a feeling thing, then the nuts come out as a kind of reward.

13. Edit as you go or shitty first draft?

JW: Neither. Neither. Every book is different. Again we’re going for these formulae prescriptions that don’t work. You take each piece of work on its own merits in its own right and you give it what it needs. One piece of work might need endless going back over for whatever reason. Another piece of work might just come flying out and you don’t know why as a kind of act of grace. 

14. How did you meet your agent?

JW: Oh, well, I’ve had more than one. You’re looking at a long life. My current agent, who’s been my agent for a long time, is Caroline Michelle at P.F.D. in the UK. I met her in 1978 when she was my publicist on The Passion. Now she runs a huge business. We sometimes look at each other and say, you know, we’ve known each other for 38 years. One of the beautiful things about getting older is that, especially if you’re a woman, you know, there are those women who stay with you and really become a kind of living diary of who you are and what you’ve done over all these years. It’s an incredible thing. And it’s something I really value about getting old. I look around and I see these amazing women like Elizabeth Schmitz at Grove, who I’ve known forever and we’re still here, girls!

15. What is your best advice for pushing through writer’s block?

JW: Never had it. It’s a con job. Really, any problem is your friend. It is not a difficulty. If you’re stuck, you need to work out why, because either it’s in your life or it’s in the work. Your unconscious, your creative self is trying to flag something to you and you have to dive deeper and go sideways and find out what’s going on. It might be in your life, it might be that you really need to take a break, or it might be in the work and you’re swerving something or trying to impose something on it. 

16. What other art forms and literary genres inspire you?

JW: I love music, and particularly classical music and opera, because it’s so ludicrous. What a ridiculous art form to invent, all those people running around on stage. I love it because it’s this sense of humans at their most gloriously ridiculous. I think with art forms, you look at them and it reminds us that we can do so much more than seeking money and power and land grab and status and starting wars and blowing up the world. Now, whenever I see any art form, it doesn’t matter what it is, I just think this is the best of us. With the way the news works, we’re surrounded all the time with the worst of humans. And that can really get you down. We’ve got to remember that we need nourishment. It’s not elitist, it’s not a luxury item. I would urge anyone to do that every day. Working every day on your deathless prose doesn’t matter, but getting nourishment from somebody else every day, even if it’s just five minutes with a poem in the morning. That matters.

17. Book club or writing group?

JW: Almighty, I’d rather clean out the cesspit without gloves if that answers your question. I’ve already told you about writing groups. And book clubs, no. I can read. I know how to read on my own. 

18. Who was the writer who made you want to write? 

JW: It didn’t happen like that. I didn’t have an ordinary beginning in life. And the only book I had for a long time was the Bible. So that’s how I learnt to write. If anybody wants to know more, read Why Be Happy When You Could Be Normal. And then all questions will be answered.

19. How do you know when you’ve reached the end of a project?

JW: I think it’s completely obvious. When people say things like that I just think if you’re a writer and you don’t know when it’s the end, you should go and do another job. I am absolutely ruthless about this. By the time you’re well over the halfway mark, which is a different place for everybody, you really should be feeling the momentum of what you’ve done. That applies to a short story as much as it does to long-form fiction. It’s a co-creator with you. You have to let it do its job.If you come to it with humility and you listen, you get the feedback from the work itself.

20. What was the last indie bookstore you went to?

JW: I’ve just been in Bulgaria, and visited an indie bookstore there, but nobody will know about that one. I’m going to cheat and say that the best thing you can do when you’re traveling to a new place is immediately find out where the closest bookstore is, because it’s likely to be independent. And go there and buy a book. You don’t have to announce yourself as a writer if you are one. You just go there, and you support the local bookshop, and I think that really makes a difference.

21. What’s an activity you do when you need to take a writing break? 

JW: I live in the country, so I can always just take a walk, which is great. I have to grow my own vegetables here and chop wood and keep the fires going and walk the dogs and so on. I don’t live a city life. In the summer things have to be watered, crops have to be planted, so on and so forth. So it’s a life that works very well for me because it’s art and nature and they do go really well together.

22. What does evolving as a writer mean to you?

JW: All you do is write each book, each set of stories, each non-fiction work, whatever it is that’s bugging you at the time, and that’s what you do. There’s no career progression. There’s just each piece of work as it turns up.

23. Outside of literature, what are you obsessed with?

JW: I’m obsessed with the state of the world at the moment. I believe that where we are now, politically, is a failure of imagination. It’s the 21st century and all we can think of to do is kill each other and trash the planet. The reason I’m always going around and doing my public-facing work and saying to people, “Look, you have to respect and nourish your imaginative capacity” is because what fiction does best of all is to take a situation and ask what if. It’s a way of refusing to be crushed by gravity, by the state of things. The way that we live isn’t a law like gravity. It’s not something that you’re subject to, whether you like it or not. This is a story we’re telling. And we could tell a better story. Anybody who tells stories for a living knows that you don’t have to have an ending you don’t want. 

Do Not Think About Death or Blowjobs

“Sixteen Hours in Iceland” by Laurie Marhoefer

It was just after midnight on the fourth of October, 2016, a Tuesday, when Ben Sullivan stepped off the flight from Berlin and became the happiest person in Keflavik Airport. It was the start of his sixteen-hour vacation from the impending death of his wife. 

In the first minutes, on the walk from the gate, Ben looked about himself, enchanted, bewildered: Iceland. A huge banner advertising volcanic hot springs. The eerie turquoise, the white steam. In the middle of the concourse, a life-sized grass-roofed hut, made of fake rocks. It sold plush trolls, wearing adorable hand-knitted sweaters. Trolls! 

He turned a corner, and the glaciers and moss gave way to dirty orange plastic tarps over scaffolding and a creaking double escalator, and suddenly it did not look as much like Iceland, but Ben didn’t mind. At the bottom of the escalator, a vast duty-free liquor sprawled, seemingly makeshift, nothing more substantial than metal shelves penned in by plastic yellow emergency barriers. It had the look of a road construction site, or a minor refugee camp, and within it, many exhausted people were loading little carts with bottles. The Icelanders behind him on the escalator pushed past and veered into the duty free, faces all bleak determination. This might have been a sign that Iceland was not what he was expecting, that in Iceland, one drank one’s way through the darkness, but Ben felt no misgivings. Rather, he felt a swell of love for the people of the duty-free. None of them saw him, a tall, pale, paunchy American with an old backpack and a messy red beard, who had been wearing the same Sonic Youth sweatshirt for five days. He had told no one that he was going to Iceland, a place that had absolutely nothing to do with anything in his real life. He had not told Tamara, his wife. He had not slept properly for a long time. He was muttering to himself, taking a childish joy in saying the name again and again: “Iceland, Iceland.” 

Heading towards the lone baggage carousel, he passed another banner image of a hot spring, which made him think of the short film “Iceland 101,” which had flashed onto the plane’s monitors just as they descended towards Keflavik Airport. The two major lessons from “Iceland 101” were, first, that if you rented a car, and you accidentally drove off the road, you should not expect to be rescued by Icelanders, or by anyone: you would die alone in the cold and the fog. Second, if you visited a hot spring, before you got into the water, in the locker room, you were to remove all of your clothing. Then, you should shower naked, with soap. Also, use a rag to scrub vigorously at your genitals. Scrub for a meaningful amount of time. To underscore this message, the video had shown a hipster guy scrubbing himself in a shower, with his genitals fuzzed out, but only just, while an Icelander, fully clothed, stood next to him and pointed. 

Ben only had sixteen hours in Reykjavik, a layover, and he did not plan to rent a car. However, in his earnest way, as the plane landed in the misty dark, he had resolved that he would scrub his genitals vigorously. It was important to the people of Iceland that he do so. He could tell it was important by how much effort they had put into the video. And with this small act, perhaps he could redeem the United States in their eyes. Though he did not think the United States was all good, it did have some good aspects, such as President Obama, who surely next year would be succeeded by President Clinton. Ben had not slept much in the five days in Berlin, or before that, in the year and a half that Tamara had had cancer. That was why this thought of President Obama, and of Ben’s own small resolve to do the right thing here in Iceland, brought a film of tears to his eyes. Then his phone buzzed. 

It must be Tamara. For days, Tamara had not been answering his texts. She was furious at him for going to Europe. But she might text, if something was wrong. What if the results of the bone marrow biopsy had come back early? It was still Monday afternoon at the hospital in Eugene. This text might say that the cancer was back. Ben froze, the baggage carousel behind him creaking, the automatic doors before him whining as they open and closed on a view of an empty parking lot under a pitch-black sky. He knew it, he felt it, as if in his own bones: these biopsy results would not be good. He took a breath, swung the bag down, fumbled the phone out. The text read, “Are you in Iceland?” 

No one in the world knew he was in Iceland. He had not told Tamara. He had not told anyone. The number was not saved in his phone. A 310 area code. It wasn’t Tamara. But who? 


Two weeks before, Tamara went back to the hospital for tests, one a blood draw, the other a biopsy of her new bone marrow. The blood test results would come in three days, the biopsy would take two weeks. These tests would tell if she was in remission. She had to pass them both. 

Like all of her cancer treatment, the tests were at the hospital where Tamara was employed, where she had risen from resident to attending. If she survived, she could never work at the hospital again, because what they called treatment for this disease was no different from long-form torture, and just the sight of the hospital building made her shake with nausea. But the biopsy was easy by comparison. By afternoon, it was done, and when they were about to leave, Penny the oncologist came out to the waiting room to see them off. Ben was gingerly doing up the snaps on Tamara’s jacket; her fingers were too weak for it. Tamara vaguely knew Penny from some hospital committee, and had always disliked her. Tamara loathed optimism. That afternoon, chipper as ever, Penny put a hand on Tamara’s shoulder and said, “Now Tamara, remember, the results will say you’re in remission, but if they don’t, all it means is more chemo.” Tamara had responded in an even voice, “I’m not a fucking idiot, Penny.” 

If Ben was being honest about the layover, the truth was that he had not thought it through. Sixteen hours was not enough time to see Reykjavik. Yet sixteen hours was a magic number of hours, the perfect number of hours. Long enough to step out of the life where Tamara had leukemia, and into another. Tamara was alright by herself for a few days. The neighbor kid would walk the dogs. 

There was just one problem. Ever since she had gotten sick, he had not missed anything.  He had seen every doctor with her, he had waited during her infusions and driven her home, he had missed nothing. He had been the best husband he could be. 

He bought the layover the day after the biopsy, a Wednesday, that evening when he came home from teaching. The front door of the house was ajar. Tamara sometimes did that so that the dogs could go in and out. But the dogs didn’t come to greet him. Tamara must be asleep with them in the bed.  

He had left her alone for too long. He ought to have come right home after class. Instead he had lingered in his office, dazed, the second lecture of the day having been the one about Poland in 1943, that village. A particularly dark lecture, a negative verdict on all of humanity, that lecture—and though he taught it every year, it had left him, as always, hollow. 

But Tamara slept most of the day now. 

Ben paused at the open door to the bedroom he no longer shared with his wife. The dogs were curled under the comforter with her. With the blackout curtains drawn, he couldn’t properly make out which nodes of blankets were dogs and which were Tamara. Because of the lecture he had just given, he thought of the humps of earth over shallow graves, then, disgusted at himself, turned and went to the couch. He ought to cook, but she never ate and he wasn’t hungry. 

These pasts months, Ben slept in the basement, on a mattress. Before the transplant, Tamara had had a lot of pain at night. The meds they gave for it did shit. Finally, he had decided it was better that he slept. “You can sleep,” she had said at the time. “You take it for granted. You’re not dying.” Tamara’s main response to her own cancer was anger. Which, Ben thought, was a useful response. But it made for some depressing moments. Though, what was the alternative, really. Terror would have been much harder to watch. 

If the test results came back shitty, he would get a sleeping bag, sleep on the floor of her hospital room, quit his job, never leave her. Though in its sixth year the marriage had not aged well, though cancer had not made the marriage work any better. But you couldn’t blame someone who was about to die at thirty-six for not loving you anymore.    

He went in the living room and slumped into the couch, too tired to turn on any lights. He put his laptop beside him, thinking that he should open it, buy the flight to that conference in Berlin. He’d asked Charlie, his department chair, to get out of it because Tamara was so sick. But Charlie had said, better not to, if at all possible, Ben had missed a lot of things over the last year and a half and this was a really important conference in Holocaust history, a conference that only happened once every two years. At least he could fly back from Berlin in time for Tamara’s biopsy results, thank God. But how to leave her. And he was so tired. 

In the living room the darkness buzzed at him. He knew this feeling, sadness so heavy it did not deserve that anodyne name. Ben tried, generally, to think about death only in the abstract, but now he saw, again, in his mind’s eye: the photograph of the market square of that village in central Poland, a snapshot taken by a soldier. It had survived the war, made its way into a museum collection, and he had shown it to his class that afternoon. Ben saw the woman again. She must have been thirty-five, thirty-six. No one from that village had survived to remember her name. There were a variety of possible deaths, some far more violent than others. But the result was the same; the person gone, and in their place, lumps, cinders, gristle. This fate awaited Tamara, too, and of course, it awaited himself. The dark in the room worked its way into his nose, his ears, like black earth.

Yet the room was not completely dark. Out the window were the rust brown oak leaves, now gray in the streetlight. He had always liked this room. They had painted it yellow when they bought the house. Their first house. Lemon yellow and a white mantel piece. (Though a few months later she decided she hated the yellow.) He had painted it. Tamara had cooked, something very complicated, trout, probably. She set the plates on a tablecloth on the floor because they had not bought furniture yet, just the mattress in the bedroom. She laid out all the food. But then she kissed him. He shoved the hyper, yipping teenager dogs, into the kitchen to keep them away from the food. He and Tamara went into the bedroom and shut the door and fucked. “Just quickly,” she had said. “The fish will get cold.” Ben had expected adult life would be mostly about love and sex. But it had turned out to be mostly about death. 

For lack of anything else, he reached for his laptop. The screen opened to a white glow. The browser showed the flight search from that morning. He hit refresh, and there it was. Iceland Air. A flight to Berlin, the same price as transferring through Amsterdam. With a sixteen-hour layover in Reykjavik. And a free night in a Reykjavik hotel. Suddenly the darkness evaporated and all Ben saw were the images on the airline website—a very shaggy pony, a hillock of lizard-green grass—fascinating simply because they were so very much alive. 

Ben had always wanted to go to Iceland. In high school, in a suburb, he had jacked off a lot to Björk. He wanted to see molten lava through a crack in the earth. He wanted to sit in a thermal hot spring. In high school in Tel Aviv, Tamara had not had any idea who Björk was, but she had always wanted to go to Iceland, too. They had talked about it.

But the return flight was the day Tamara would get the biopsy results.  If he flew directly home to Eugene from Berlin, he would be home in time. If he went to Reykjavik for sixteen hours, he would be on a plane thirty thousand feet over the tundra of northern Canada when Tamara found out if she was going to die. 

Tamara padded into the living room draped in a blanket. 

 “Do you want something to eat?” Ben asked. 

“You eat,” she said. She went down the hall. The bathroom door clicked shut. He looked again at the flight, the hotel. He had never missed anything for her cancer before. He would not buy a crazy sixteen-hour layover in Iceland. 

He heard the toilet flush, the sink running. Then Tamara crossed the living room in the old white comforter. She hesitated in the door of the bedroom, leaned on the door frame. She said, “I got the CBC results.” That was the first test, the blood test. 

“What?” He got up, followed her into the bedroom, where she crawled into the bed, amidst the dogs. The blood test results were not supposed to come back till tomorrow. “When?” he said. 

“While you were at work,” she said. 

Why hadn’t she called him. She propped herself up in the bed with some pillows, pulled her computer from the bedside table to her lap. Then she said, “It was clear.” 

He took a step towards her but she put up her hand. “No,” she said. “Don’t. It was clear, but I did something stupid. I googled.” 

The entire time she had been sick, Tamara had forbidden him to look things up on the internet, that is, things about her illness. Half the time all the internet did was cough up outdated research she had said, and being a doctor, though a rheumatologist, she would know. But Ben suspected that was not the real reason. The real reason was that the odds of survival were so bleak, he and Tamara were better off not knowing. But now, at the end, she had googled. She must have had hope. 

 “Everybody gets a clean CBC at this point,” she said. “Here I was terrified about the CBC. But with my genes the odds of a clean biopsy are awful.” 

“Sweetie,” he said, an old name for her, it had been months since he had used it.

“Oh, shut up, Ben,” she said. “Don’t try to tell me it’s not true.” She opened the laptop. She was on leave from the hospital, but she still spent hours reading through the resident’s notes; she did not trust residents. Ben stood in the doorway for a long time, watching her click through files. Finally, he decided there was nothing he could say. So he began to explain about the flight, the conference, Berlin. Just as he was about to assure her that he would fly back in time, he would be here when she got the biopsy results, that whatever happened, he would be here, she cut him off. She said, “Yes, fine. Go and talk about the Holocaust in Berlin. You’re into dead Jews. That’s your favorite kind, isn’t it.” 

He was gripped, suddenly, by the memory of that summer ten years ago, she came to Berlin, when he was in grad school researching his dissertation and living over a Turkish grocery. He rode her around on the back of his bike, her arms around his waist as they crossed the canal bridge, and he laughed at her black-hearted Israeli Holocaust jokes. Every time they saw the u-Bahn go by she would make a very dark joke about German trains. How he loved her. Maybe she was teasing him again, now. But no, he could tell—the set of her jaw, the clipped, furious way she pronounced the “d” in “dead”—this wasn’t kidding. 

A wish came to him, a strong wish, rising up in his chest: that they would divorce. She could move back to Tel Aviv. Apparently—and this he would never understand—she wanted to go back, she had come full circle. When Ben had first met her, she had talked so much about how she would never, ever go back. He had no right to have any opinion about Tel Aviv, beyond admiring the beaches. She would be the first to say so. Never mind that. The wish was that they would get divorced. The biopsy would show no cancer. People got divorced at 36. They didn’t die at 36. 

He said, “I’ll get back from Berlin Tuesday night. After you get the biopsy results.”   

  “I don’t care,” she said.

Years ago, he had broken down about all of the murdered, because there were so many, crowding around. He told her he couldn’t finish the book, ever, because what was a book, why did a book matter. He stopped writing. That Berlin couple in their eighties, the lawyer and his wife who had been a music teacher. After they got the notice to come to the police station the next morning, he had reminded her to bring stamps so when they got to the labor camp they could write their son in England. 

He told her he couldn’t finish the book, ever, because what was a book, why did a book matter.

And Tamara had said, but you are writing it down, that means something, you are making it so the murderers cannot hide.  

Tamara went on, “It really is. Your favorite kind of Jew. You wrote two books about dead Jews. And lucky you, you don’t have to be one.” She went back to typing, the screen’s glow sharpening the shadows of her spectrally gaunt face.  

Ben went back into the living room and bought the flight to Iceland. Because it might be too late for her. But at least he would have those sixteen hours. 


On the transatlantic flight, guilt should have eaten him: he was abandoning his wife. Instead, he felt elation: he was abandoning his wife. He did not sleep. He drank coffee and read, a new book about Lichtefelde, the fancy Berlin suburb, the upper-middle-class elite and the years of Nazi rule, filling in the gaps in his knowledge on the middle-class reaction to fascism—understanding it better did not make it better, but it gave him some hope. His was the only light on in the whole plane. He got up and walked the aisle, his feet floating as if gravity had slackened its grip, and he pictured the dark Atlantic, so far below. 

At the conference, it was more of the minutia of German history in the 1930s, panel presentation after panel presentation in a lecture hall at the university, fascinating—even after all this time, they were still getting better at understanding why it had happened. He forgot about Tamara for long stretches. He texted but she never texted back. He kept his phone out, face up on the empty chair next to him, or on his knee, in case she texted, in case something happened and she needed him, but she did not. At night, back at the hotel, he called her. She didn’t pick up. 

On Monday, the conference’s last day, he sat on a folding chair near a slight man with olive skin and dark hair swept in a wave above his forehead. He wore an expensive coat, a beautiful maroon boiled-wool, with a sharp collar folded up past his ears. Ben recalled that this guy was not a historian. He was the artist-in-residence of the conference, a radio producer researching a podcast, or something. At the podium, one of the senior historians from the Freie Üniversität gave a paper on the Berlin deportations. The radio producer took notes by hand in a palm-sized paperback journal and chewed the end of his pencil. Then his pencil broke, and he asked Ben if he had an extra. Ben only had a pen. 

“I’m going to chew it,” he whispered. “Is that OK?” 

Ben nodded. 

They went back to listening to the paper as the radio producer demolished the end of the pen. When the session ended he handed it back with a long, sheepish look and a little grin. What was it about this guy, Ben wondered. It was as if he had met him somewhere before. 

The conference ended with one of those staged conversations, the conference director interviewing the radio producer, his name was Elliott Rosen, about his podcast. He was making a series about the life of a German Jew named Charlotte Charlaque, who was transgender. She survived, got out before the deportations, and lived in Brooklyn for decades. Ben had written two books about Berlin Jews and the Holocaust, but he had never heard of Charlotte Charlaque. Elliott Rosen said how her story had been hidden for so many years, and at times his voice shook ever so slightly in anger. It was one of the most compelling research talks Ben had ever heard. 

At the reception afterwards, Ben had three beers and two sausages, standing in a corner with his friends from grad school, Helene and that crowd, who were going on and on about tenure, or, alternatively, about the new book on Operation Reinhardt—“a whisp of a book, three slipshod chapters and a meaningless conclusion,” Helene called it. He was only half listening. Elliott was by the buffet, surrounded by admirers. He reminded Ben of someone, but who? Ben did not often think about what people were wearing, but it was hard not to notice that Elliott was dressed like someone who had money, someone in the movie business, and the historians flocking around him were dressed like historians, that is, as if they had borrowed their parents’ business casual in the 1990s and not returned it. 

Ben had been with guys—a fair number of them, in fact. But not since college. He had not been with anyone but Tamara in six years. He realized why Elliott seemed familiar. He reminded Ben of those college bars, those guys, before Tamara. Was Elliott gay? he wondered. Was he trans? He must be. Could a trans guy be gay? Ben had never been with a trans guy. He was not sure he had ever met one. 

“Ben,” said Helene, “Go talk to the radio producer.” 

“What?” Ben said. 

“The, ah, person he’s writing about, it’s just like your second book,” she said. “Minus the transgender part.” She laughed. “That’s a first, isn’t it?” 

“Uh,” Ben said. 

Helene dragged him through the crowd, elbowing the octogenarian historian bending Elliott’s ear, and introduced Ben as an expert on the Berlin deportations. 

“Oh, that’s amazing,” said Elliott. “And I ate your pen! But you’re exactly the person I—” 

Two of the conference organizers—nervous junior faculty at the FU—cut in. Elliott had to come for a picture, right now; so-and-so, some very senior person, was leaving. Elliott promised to come back. “You’ll wait, won’t you?” Elliott smiled, a half-smile, and cocked his head. He had dark eyes, and he was looking at Ben so intently that a shiver ran up the back of Ben’s neck, this was not a usual look, not just a friendly look, it was something more, Ben knew that look. He’s gay, he thought. He thinks I’m gay. 

“Uh, sure,” said Ben. “I have a flight but—” 

“See you in a second.” Elliott squeezed Ben’s forearm. Then the two organizers whisked him off through the crowd. 

Helene hissed, “Tell him to put you in the podcast!” 

“I have to go,” said Ben, flushing. He had a flight to Reykjavik at 10 pm. And he was married, to someone who was dying. He had to go. Helene walked him out. She asked after Tamara, in that meaningful way that people do when they think someone’s number has come up. Ben lied and said Tamara was doing much better. 

At the airport, at the gate, he texted Tamara. She did not text back. He walked up and down the empty concourse, giant, echoing, ominous blond wood and black metal, wondering if Elliott would notice that he had left the reception, wondering if he should email Elliott and determining not to, because he was married, to a dying person. Tomorrow, as he was flying over Canada, the biopsy results would come back, and then, he would get a taxi home, it would be late at night, she would be asleep but the nightmare would begin. If the biopsy was bad, the nightmare would begin. Until then, he had his sixteen hours. 

His seat was in the very last row of the plane, snug up by the bathroom. Ben took out the Iceland guidebook. He would get to the hotel, sleep a few hours, wake up at 6 am, and he only had to be back at the airport at 2 pm, he’d have virtually the entire day in Reykjavik. But he should make a plan. That bright blue hot spring in the guidebook photograph, or the hike up the mountain. They got held at the gate for a while, a scrum of commotion way up the aisle toward the front, last-minute passengers boarding late, and a flight attendant got on the PA to announce how everyone was being held up by these late-comers. This was northern Europe, after all, no sympathy at all for the failings of others, a trait Tamara appreciated, he recalled. He put the guidebook into the seat back pocket and gave in, thought about Elliott. Elliott had the look of a bird, somehow. Like if a bird went to the gym a lot and got jacked. Was Elliott trans? He never would have thought so. Did it matter? 

Ben had a feeling that he would get to the hotel in Reykjavik and have a wank about this Elliott, even if he got to the hotel at two in the morning. He had not thought about sex since Tamara got sick. He rubbed at his beard, disgusted by himself. It was dumb to get a boner on a plane about an (admittedly good looking, very square-jawed) guy, when your wife was dying. But it didn’t matter. He would be in Iceland soon. A thousand miles away from Elliott the hot radio producer. He should read the guidebook and make a plan, because he only had sixteen hours, and the only way this was going to work is if he made a careful plan. Instead he closed his eyes and thought about Elliott whispering in his ear and giving him a hand job.


Who had a 310 area code? Ben stood there, baffled, between the baggage carousel and the automatic doors and whatever lay ahead, Iceland itself. Then another text from the same number came in, “Are you in the airport in Iceland right now looking at your phone?” 

He looked up. “Oh my god.”  

Elliott was ten feet away. “I wasn’t sure it was you!” he said. “You look like a Viking but so does every other guy in this airport, but that sweatshirt—that’s your only sweatshirt? Your friend gave me your number!”  

Elliott had been on his plane. He had not been able to find Ben at the reception, where had Ben got to? And then Elliott had almost missed the flight. The starstruck historians had not wanted to let him go; he had had to take a cab. “Then I sprinted! They were just about to close the door, the gate agent wasn’t going to let me on the plane, but I smiled at him like this—” Elliott smiled at Ben, eyes narrowed, as if he was smiling at Ben over a nearly empty glass of wine in a Parisian hotel elevator, ascending to a bedroom on the eleventh floor—“And then he did let me on the plane.” Months ago, Elliott had seen the same affordable flight, with the same free hotel. He, however, was wisely staying longer than sixteen hours. Elliott lived in Los Angeles and had a lot of friends, none of whom had cancer, and they had planned a multi-day hiking trip. The friends were renting a car and weren’t getting in till tomorrow. 

Out in the drizzle and the dark by the curb, where the only shuttle bus into the city arrived and departed, they learned that there was only one person who sold the bus tickets, loaded all the luggage, and presumably would drive the bus, and that he was unhappy. The shuttle bus line was long, it was 1 am, and so they looked for a taxi, and learned that there was only one cab, for the whole airport, and that it had left already. Elliott huddled into his beautiful coat. They could see their breath in the air. The Icelanders waiting for the bus smoked, their faces clenched, grim. Keflavik, Iceland’s major airport, hunched behind them. It was about the size and look of an art museum in a small city that was surprised and lucky to have an art museum, such as Utica, New York—a small, poorly kept up concrete building, its windows clouded by the grime that had built up over the decades. 

When they got on the bus there was no way not to sit next to Elliott. It was much, much farther to the city than Ben expected. They passed through an uninhabited, desolate country. 

“I’m so glad I ran into you,” Elliott said. “You wrote a book about the deportations from Berlin, Helene said.” 

Ben agreed and decided not to mention that in fact, it was two books, because that might sound excessive, as if he had a thing for dead Jews. 

“You must know so much about history!” Elliott said. “You’re married, aren’t you?”  

“Not—,” said Ben. “Uh, yes.”   

“And you have children,” Elliott said, “and you live in a suburb, and you are happy?” 

“I have two dogs,” Ben said. His heart was pounding. “I mean, we have two dogs. They’re old now.” Then he added, and immediately regretted it, “I’m not straight, I mean, I used to date guys. In college.” He flushed, why had he said such a stupid thing? 

“And you only have the one sweatshirt?” 

“Uh, I don’t have many sweatshirts, no.” 

Elliott smiled, reached over, and squeezed Ben’s knee. Then he withdrew his slender hand and launched, too quickly, into what was ostensibly a historical question about Charlotte Charlaque, what she might have had to do to get a visa to the United States, how she had escaped the Holocaust, but was really a long story about her life, resplendent with detail, told in a way that made it plain to Ben how much Elliott loved the subject of his documentary, though she had died before he was born, though she was no gender revolutionary, Elliott allowed, though she was prone to personal drama and kept spending her meager funds on clothing instead of food, though she ignored lots of practical advice from the doctor Harry Benjamin and instead had long cocktail evenings with his wife, Gretchen. 

It was dark on the bus. The other passengers slept. Elliott was so close that Ben could smell his hair product. It had a faint, reassuring, manly scent to it, perhaps sage; Ben did not know the names of things that smelled. Elliott’s pants were brown, of that checkered fabric—was it called houndstooth? Ben had an urge to brush the back of his hand against Elliott’s leg. His hand was so close to Elliott’s thigh. It would take almost no more effort to reach out and do it than to simply imagine doing it. 

Just then the bus pulled into what looked like an abandoned gas station in the middle of a desolate moor but turned out not to be abandoned at all, and in fact, to be Reykjavik’s major bus terminal. They got out and stamped their feet in the cold and after a while, the tired and defeated bus driver led them to a fleet of sad-looking mini vans. He and Elliott had a van to themselves, the lonely van bound for Íslandshótel Grand Centrum. Now there were one-story houses here and there, and a few streetlights. It was 2 am. Ben had a moment to think. 

He had not had sex with anyone but Tamara in six years. But he doubted he had the power of mind not to end up in bed with this guy when they got to the hotel. They were at the same damn hotel! He couldn’t. He couldn’t be in bed with someone on the day she got the biopsy results. He couldn’t be in bed with someone who made podcasts. Tamara hated podcasts.  

They were passing a lake. Modest white houses, dark windows. No people, and no trees. Just the dark moor. Ben resolved to look out the window and to think only about leukemia and about what a moral garbage fire he was until his boner receded. He took a deep breath of the fetid van air. 

Ben resolved to think only about leukemia and about what a moral garbage fire he was until his boner receded.

“I wanted to ask you something,” Elliott said. 

Fuck, thought Ben, but thank god, it was not about sex. Elliott said, “My mom’s mom’s parents, they were from Berlin, but they didn’t get out in time.” His manner had changed. His voice was slow. As if it was an effort to speak. “We don’t really know what happened to them. I was wondering if you could tell me where I could go. To look something like that up. If there are books. I mean, to know how they died.” 

Oh no, thought Ben. He had wanted this guy to blow him. He had sat and pictured that, on and off, for an hour, with the guy right next to him. And the whole time, the guy was being friendly because he was working up the nerve to find out how his great-grandparents had died in the Holocaust. I am truly a moral garbage fire, he thought. 

Elliott went on, “I know it’s probably not possible. I guess they could have been deported to any number of places—” 

“No,” Ben said. “No, it’s easy to find out. I can help you. I just, I just. I mean. I’m sorry.” He was sorry. He would never think of a blowjob again, ever. 

Elliott went on, “I thought maybe I could look them up at the Jewish Museum in Berlin but they don’t do that. This guy I’m dating—well, was dating, anyway—he said, did I really want to know, wouldn’t it make it worse? I guess that’s what my mom thinks. But I feel like I owe it to them.” 

If you were a historian of the Holocaust, over time, you realized, that part of the job was, people wanted to know things like this, but they didn’t know how to find out. You ran into people, occasionally, who had lost relatives but didn’t know what had become of them. When the war finally ended, there had been no neighbors to write to the relatives who had managed to flee abroad. The whole city had been wiped out, all together, in an afternoon. Now, all these years later, the family members still wanted to know, and they had an old document, and they asked if Ben could translate it, perhaps it was a clue. Or, they had the name of an obscure camp, outside a tiny town in the Ukraine, did he know what kind of camp it was?

The news was never good. Elliott was going to be sad. 

The van stopped outside of a two-story building, corrugated steel, and the driver announced: Íslandshótel Grand Centrum. It appeared closed for the night. As they pulled their bags out of the back of the van, the driver recommended that they look behind them, to see the Parliament of Iceland. Then he drove off, the van’s exhaust leaving dragon swirls in the night air. They turned and saw, across a small, grass city square, an elegant but unassuming two-story concrete building, about the size of Ben’s high school: the Parliament of Iceland. Bisecting the grassy square was a footpath, and along it was a single statue and a single bench. On the bench, people in sleeping bags were drinking peacefully.  

“That’s the parliament,” said Elliott. “Look at it, Ben Sullivan. Think about it. How many people can live here, if that’s the parliament? Do you know what that means? We actually stand a chance of running into Björk! Is the hotel open?” 

They peered in the window of the hotel. No one was at the desk. Ben banged on the door. After a while, a teenager in a hoody came. He checked them in, first Elliott, then Ben. As he did, Ben explained to Elliott about the various databases: one was public, he could send Elliott the link, but the largest was ITS, set up by the Red Cross after the war, and 90% of it wasn’t public. If Elliott could send him his grandparents’ names and birth dates, Ben would look, he had access for work. Now that everything was digital, it was so easy to run names through ITS. The quickness of it still stunned him, every time. Years ago, it took months, an exchange of letters with the office in Bad Arlosen, Germany, it took someone there actually walking to a giant warehouse, pulling paper cards from files. Now it was the work of fifteen minutes, the work of small muscles, fingers only. So quick now, the little path to the abyss. 

Their rooms were up a curving staircase set with wall niches. The niches held statues of Vikings battling serpentine monsters, tentacles wrapping around bulky necks and bare legs. Despite their dire circumstances, the Vikings did not seem entirely unhappy. Awkwardly, Ben followed Elliott. His room was right across the hall, of course. 

“Maybe I’ll see you tomorrow,” Elliott said. Ben had explained that he had to go back to the airport at 2 pm. “Maybe I won’t, though. You’ll leave early in the morning to climb the volcano, and to sit in the hot spring.” Elliott looked directly into his eyes, as if he knew exactly what Ben felt just then.  

What Ben felt was so much lust that for a second, he though his knees would give out. They did not. His face turned that stupid pink again, he could tell, but he nevertheless held it utterly rigid. “I’ll email you,” he said. Then he turned, robot-like, unlocked his hotel door, went inside, and pulled it shut, click. 

It was 2:50 am. He got into the shower. He stood for a long time with his head pressed against the tiles, every now and then turning the water temperature down, until it got so cold he began to shake. Then he got out. He wrote Elliott the email about the database. Then he took two Benadryl and four melatonin, set his alarm for 5:55 am, and went to sleep. 

His phone woke him. It was 4:18 am. The text was from Elliott. It read, “Are you still awake?”  

Fuck, thought Ben. Oh fuck. He couldn’t get one of his eyes to open. How many Benadryl had he taken? He rolled out of the bed and landed on the floor on all fours. Why would a person text from across the hall at 4:18 am? Oh, he knew why, he did. It made him intensely happy, a happy he was not supposed to feel, and really, really was not supposed to feel, because: Tamara’s biopsy results. When, tomorrow? He looked again at the phone. The little dots blinked. “Can I come over,” Elliott wrote.

The glowing words seemed alive, creatures crouching in the Benadryl fog. But why hadn’t he thought before. About how, if the biopsy was bad, the next year of his life was going to be a horror movie, and he would never recover. Just one blowjob. In Iceland. Where sea monsters haunted the freezing black currents. Where the horns were sounding in the forest of life. 

“Yes,” Ben typed. 

“It’s not about sex,” Elliott wrote. 

Ben was crushed. He shook himself. Death, then. The database. Of course. It was always that. Ben got up and began to dress, for death. His boner wilted.   

Elliott knocked. He hadn’t even gone to bed. The houndstooth pants remained. “I couldn’t find my great-grandparents in the database,” he said. “I woke you up, didn’t I. I’m sorry.” He was troubled, his wry grin gone. “I couldn’t sleep. I wasn’t sure what time you would leave, if I would miss you in the morning. I wanted to know.” 

Ben went to the desk by the bed, to his laptop. “What were their names?”  

“Thank you,” said Elliott. After a while, as Ben scrolled through the list of names, looking for people from Berlin, Elliott said, “I guess I didn’t want to be alone with it.” 

Ben didn’t know what to say.   

He found them. It took longer than fifteen minutes, but not longer than thirty. Then he had a date, the date of their transport from Berlin. December 15, 1941, in the early morning. You could tell so much if you had the date. He could tell where they were sent, how they died. But you could go in the other direction, too, to the before. They must have lived in the western part of the city. In one of those leafy suburbs. Yes, here was an address. Elliott sat on the bed and took notes in his little journal.  

“Lichterfelde. They probably had a good life there, before ’33,” said Ben. He told Elliott about life in the suburb. He had read about it on the plane. All the trees, the little shops, the choral societies and the Zionist lectures and the B’nai B’rith lodge. Maybe they were proud of their daughter. She had been a journalist and a communist, had gotten arrested early and then fled the country, had tried to bring them but couldn’t get the visas, Elliott had said. What Ben meant to say was, the end of their lives was not the whole story of their lives. Probably the end was not the only thing they would have wanted their great-grandson to know about them. He tried to say that, in stumbling words. He was OK at dates but so bad at words. Elliott looked down at his journal. Ben felt then that he had said the wrong thing, that he should have said nothing, or that he should say something more. But he could not think of what. 

After a while, Elliott said, “To be completely honest, I don’t think you have time to get to a thermal spring without a rental car. There’s a public pool with hot pots in the west town. It’s ten Kroná and it opens at 5:30.” 

They walked across the city in the dark and waited outside the public pool, with a cluster of very old people. Ben tried to think of something else to say, something better, about Elliott’s great-grandparents. What he had said had been stupid, but he couldn’t think of anything else. In the face of death, what was there to say. After a few minutes, an older woman unlocked the doors and sold them tickets from behind a Plexiglas shield. She begrudgingly rented them towels. Then she frowned and jabbed her finger towards a large sign. It explained in English how to shower before getting in the pool, how to scrub one’s genitals. There was also a diagram. 

As they hung their coats in the wooden lockers and sat on a bench to take off their shoes, Ben said, “You have to really scrub. Scrub so they can see you’re scrubbing, you know, because they hate Americans. And it’s important to them as a nation. The scrubbing is.” 

Elliott scowled. “Oh, fuck that.” 

“What?” In the midst of stepping out of his underwear, Ben jolted, tripped, jumped on one leg, and saved himself from toppling over.  

Elliott, who was still fully dressed, said, “Has it occurred to you, a trans guy might not want to scrub his dick in public?” 

It had not. 

“Seriously.” Elliott smiled sweetly as he unbuttoned his shirt, but he was pissed, Ben could tell. “This is a plot to see my dick. All the posters, that angry lady, the movie on the plane, all of it. You think that’s paranoia but listen, cisgender people always want to know what transgender people have going on.” 

Ben had himself wanted to know that—very intensely, he realized, to his mortification. He began to stammer, but then Elliott said, “Don’t worry, buddy. I bet you will scrub your dick good enough for both of us.” 

Ben had no idea how to respond, so instead he kicked off his underwear. Now, he was naked, and it was time. He would do right by the people of Iceland. He could not figure out how to talk to Elliott, and Tamara hated his guts, and he could not fix the whole horrible human world. But he could scrub the hell out of his nuts, perhaps thereby sparking a tiny, fragile hope in the heart of a stranger. 

He turned his back on Elliott. He crossed the locker room, hulking past bent, naked old men, into the shower area, where more wrinkled men were scrubbing their genitals raw. Ben turned on a shower, right in the middle where all could see, squared his shoulders, and scrubbed with a towel. He scrubbed his genitals for far longer than he ever had before. Also, he scrubbed his ass. After a while, he glanced up. There was Elliott under the shower in the corner, his back to him, his head up, the water striking the middle of his chest. He was not scrubbing. But his ass and his dark hair were so beautiful that Ben did not care. 

Dripping, Ben put on his suit, and he was aware that in his peripheral vision, Elliott was doing the same, though Ben tried not to look. Then they went out barefoot to the pool deck. The sun had not risen, but there were weak electric lights above the big pool, which was empty, save for one very old woman swimming a slow breaststroke. The concrete was cold under his feet. The hot pots were small round pools and the hottest of them made Elliott screech. They settled into one that according to signage, Icelanders considered to be medium-temperature, so hot that just putting his calves in was excruciating. He had to wait a full minute to go to his knees. The walls of the hot pot were painted pale green. The water was absolutely still. Elliott’s shoulders were slight, like the crook of a bird’s wing. Ben set his phone on the deck, a little black stone on the gray, wet concrete. She was asleep now, but in case something happened in the night, in case she texted. 

The air smelled like rain and chlorine. There was no wind. Through the chain link fence the streetlights cast soft shadows into the water. It was 6:15 am. 

His phone, the little stone, buzzed. But it was midnight in Eugene. Something was wrong. He slid the texting ap open. It was Tamara. He read the words. She was sorry. The biopsy results had come back, they had come back a day early, she had not called, that was why she was sorry. The results were clear. No cancer.  

It was as if he had been kicked in the stomach. Ben read the words again. The biopsy was clear, no cancer. The pain in his stomach built into a great black spike. He clenched his jaw but a groan escaped.  

“What is it,” Elliott said, his voice coming as if through a mile of cotton. 

Then, suddenly, the agony in his gut evaporated. He took a breath. He had to call her. He had to go call her. Why hadn’t she told him? She had known for hours. Hours! He switched off his phone. Through the chain link fence, the sky had gone a faint pink. There was rain coming, he could smell it. It washed over him, then: Tamara would not die of cancer this year. A good thing had happened. She was spared. He had come to this remote land, where beautiful men stood beside him in the shower, and he had gotten away from death. 

And he had left her. Could this be the end, then? The end of the marriage? 

Elliott was watching him from the opposite bench, the hot pot was so small that their knees almost touched. Elliott said, “Are you OK?” 

“Yes,” said Ben. 

“What happened?”

“I have to call my wife. But I wanted to, uh, say something to you. I’m sorry about your family. I never know what to say, but I’m sorry.” 

“Oh, the Holocaust, you mean?” Elliott laughed. “It’s thoughtful of you to apologize for the Holocaust. You’ve really been very considerate about the Shoah, getting up in the middle of the night with me and all that. But let’s be done with it. It happened before we were born.” He paused, then said, in a quieter voice, “you can go call your wife. I’ll probably be here when you come back.” 

Yes, that was right, Ben would call her. Maybe Tamara would feel different now, maybe she would say she loved him. Though he could never truly be there for her, he had tried. Maybe she would see that now, now that she wasn’t going to die. But if she did, if she said as much, would he have to stay married to her? All those hours, she hadn’t called him. She had gone to bed, probably, been unable to sleep.

Ben looked up. Elliott was still watching him. Ben said, “And I’m sorry I was insensitive about your dick.”  

“You are apologizing a lot.” Elliott said. Then he leaned across the pool and put his palm against Ben’s cheek. His hand was wet, hot from the pool. “Ugh,” he said. “You’re married. But you’re so, so sad, about the Holocaust. Why do I find that sexy? You’re a bear, a sad bear, sad about the Holocaust. It should creep me out but it’s hot. What is wrong with me.”  

Under the water, Ben slid his hand onto Elliott’s thigh.  

The Most Anticipated Literary Adaptations Coming to TV and Film in 2026

For avid readers, literary adaptations can be a source of both excitement and contention. Will the visual language of the film match the landscape in your head? Can the director capture that elusive magic of the prose? Translate the descriptive worldbuilding? In 2025, our literary adaptations list was one of the most popular articles of the year, and with a combination of enthralling stories and talented casts, it’s easy to see why! Readers turned to their big (and small) screens to see Bong Joon Ho’s Mickey 17, Guillermo del Toro’s Frankenstein, and Edgar Wright’s The Running Man

This year, we’ve got an all-new lineup of adaptations in the pipeline, from Emerald Fennell’s pop-emblazened reimagining of Wuthering Heights to Christopher Nolan’s star-studded rendition of The Odyssey. It’s clear that readers hold the film counterparts of such beloved titles to a high standard, especially with respect to textual accuracy and casting choices. Emerald Fennell has already received backlash for neglecting Brontë’s nuanced exploration of both race and class by casting a white actor as Heathcliff. Nolan has also met with criticism for his film’s lack of Mediterranean actors and the decision to opt for huge Hollywood stars as a box office draw.

Regardless of whether these stories are making it to theaters or debuting as a limited series on streaming, one thing is for sure: When it comes to the stories we hold closest, readers look for nothing short of excellence. As the year progresses, we’ll find out if these adaptations break our hearts, or rise to the challenges of their source material. 

People We Meet on Vacation by Emily Henry

Emily Henry—foremost expert of the beach read—combines love, travel, and crossed wires in People We Meet on Vacation. The book follows long-time friends Poppy and Alex, whose budding attraction is derailed when their yearly vacation goes awry, and a misunderstanding leads to a rift between them. The film adaptation, directed by Brett Haley and starring Emily Bader, Tom Blyth, and Lukas Gage, debuted on Netflix on January 9th. 

Wuthering Heights by Emily Brontë

There are few books with literary reputations that rival Emily Brontë’s Wuthering Heights. Coincidentally, Saltburn director Emerald Fennell has a reputation of her own, and she’s putting it all on the table with a new, controversial adaptation of the classic story. Following the gothic love affair between Heathcliff and Catherine Earnshaw on the Yorkshire moors, Fennell’s rendition promises erotic tension, vibrant aesthetics, and an all new album from Charli XCX as the accompanying score. Starring Margot Robbie and Jacob Elordi, the film is set to debut in theaters on February 13, 2026.

Project Hail Mary by Andy Weir

Andy Weir’s Project Hail Mary follows school teacher and biologist Ryland Grace, who wakes up on the Hail Mary spaceship with no memory of how he arrived there. When an alien microbe is discovered as the cause of the sun’s rapid dimming, researchers—and the reluctant Ryland—must race for a solution. The film is co-directed by Phil Lord and Christopher Miller, scheduled for release on March 20th, 2026, and, most importantly, stars Ryan Gosling. 

East of Eden by John Steinbeck

John Steinbeck’s imaginative retelling of the Cain and Abel story is getting a limited series—and we can’t wait to see it. Taking place in Central California’s Salinas Valley, East of Eden is a story of family, betrayal, and contradiction. Directed by Zoe Kazan—whose legendary grandfather Elia Kazan directed the 1955 adaptation starring James Dean—the series will span seven episodes, and will star Florence Pugh, Mike Faist, and Christopher Abbott, among others. Although an exact release date isn’t known, viewers can anticipate seeing the show on Netflix sometime between February and April.

Three Bags Full by Leonie Swann

Leonie Swann’s Three Bags Full—originally published in 2005—is finally getting a screen adaptation in the form of Kyle Balda’s The Sheep Detectives. The story, told from the sheep’s perspective, begins with the flock returning from a day out in the pasture to find that their shepherd has been murdered. Without the advantage of language, the sheep must use unconventional strategies to piece together details from human conversations in order to find the murderer. This wooly romp is set to debut in theaters on May 8th, 2026, and will star Hugh Jackman and Emma Thompson, with voice appearances from Julia Louis-Dreyfus, Bryan Cranston, Chris O’Dowd, and more!

The Odyssey by Homer

In 2026, Christopher Nolan is taking on Homer’s formidable epic poem. The story—familiar to high school students and literary scholars alike—follows Odysseus, king and hero of the Trojan War, as he encounters mythical monsters, goddesses, and serendipitous foils on his perilous journey home. Nolan is reaching new heights with both the film’s budget and its cast of performers that includes Matt Damon, Anne Hathaway, Tom Holland, Zendaya, Charlize Theron, Robert Pattinson, Lupita Nyong’o, and more. The film will debut in US theaters on July 17th, 2026.

The Dog Stars by Peter Heller

Peter Heller’s The Dog Stars is a particularly resonant tale for our current world. In the aftermath of a decimating pandemic, pilot Hig lives in an airplane hangar with his dog and one human companion, a brusque former marine. After months of solitude, an unexpected sign of life sparks renewed hope and sets off a search for the source. This story of resilience and resourcefulness will be directed by Ridley Scott, and is set to star Jacob Elordi, Josh Brolin, and Margaret Qualley, with a release date of August 28th, 2026.

Sense and Sensibility by Jane Austen

I’ve always been particularly intrigued by adaptations of Jane Austen novels. Austen’s prose is ornate and evocative, and it can be a fascinating challenge to render for a contemporary cast and audience. Sense and Sensibility, Austen’s first novel, follows three sisters of little fortune, Elinor, Marianne, and Margaret, as they struggle to make advantageous (and romantically appealing) marital alliances. This newest adaptation—set to release in the US on September 11th, 2026—is directed by Georgia Oakley, and will star Daisy Edgar-Jones, Esmé Creed-Miles, and Frank Dillane, among others.

The Magician’s Nephew by C.S. Lewis

For her newest directorial venture, Greta Gerwig is taking on a beloved classic: The Chronicles of Narnia. Although it’s the sixth published book in the series, The Magician’s Nephew takes place at the story’s outset. The tale interweaves an origin narrative for the kingdom—offering context for beloved characters from The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobewith the story of two English children who time travel to the mythical kingdom. The film is set to star Emma Mackey, Carey Mulligan, and Daniel Craig, and will be released on Netflix on November 26, 2026.

Fanfiction Made Me a Literary Scholar

Last year, I was given a deeply nostalgic gift: Illumicrate’s beautiful exclusive editions of Trudi Canavan’s Black Magician Trilogy—a series that had been one of my favorites in my late teens—complete with embossed hardback covers and Diana Dworak’s new endpaper artwork. Reading this series again prompted me to log back into FanFiction.net, a website where I was once a frequent reader and contributor, for the first time in over a decade. I clicked on a BMT fanfic that sounded interesting and curled up with a cup of tea in cozy delight. 

As I read, something about the prose felt strangely familiar. By chapter two, I was laughing out loud. I was reading my own fic, written when I was sixteen. Eighteen years on, it was still online, having accrued a respectable number of favorites on its (somewhat melodramatic) fourteen-thousand-word story. It felt like a full circle moment, as if I had unexpectedly met an old friend. But it was also bittersweet, because somewhere between earning three degrees in English literature—then becoming a lecturer and publishing my first academic book—the teenager who had glued herself to a desktop computer after school to write fiction for pleasure had disappeared. And yet, I wouldn’t be here today without her.

Long before I learned what close reading meant, or encountered intimidating phrases like intertextuality, narrative theory, or hermeneutics, I was already practicing them—just in a very different classroom. My training ground was not a school or library, but LiveJournal communities updated at 2 a.m., FictionAlley.org profiles with glittering pixel art, and the niche depths of Archive Of Our Own where writers of all ages performed feats of narrative ambition that my own undergraduate students today rarely have the chance to attempt. Fanfiction was where I first learned to read attentively, write un-self-consciously, and to take seriously the complex relationship between text and reader, author and interpreter, canon and “fanon.” I was conducting close linguistic analysis simply to capture the cadence of a particular character: After all, you didn’t want to get comments from invested readers complaining “this is too OOT” (Out Of Character). I would rearrange the narrative structure of my own fics because I had loved the pacing of someone else’s. I would self-edit to feedback from readers according to what was landing well. All of it felt like play. But it was also an education. When I later sat in university lectures learning about focalization, diegesis, and narrative tension, I felt a quiet recognition. I had been doing this sort of work for years; I simply had not known its name. 

My training ground was not a school or library, but LiveJournal communities.

When I stepped into academia, I quickly learned how little respect this world earned. That I read and wrote fanfiction was something to hide. As a university student, I assiduously worked through my reading lists, genuinely enjoying some of the set texts (the high fantasy fan in me raced through The Iliad, and Shakespeare’s comedies were never a chore)—but I wasn’t about to tell my Latin-speaking, private-school-educated, white middle-class peers that I already knew what a good paragraph looked like because I’d spent the better part of high school writing and reviewing fanfic. Being a multi-ethnic, international school kid from Turkey with an inexplicably American accent was already plenty to explain. So, bit by bit, I got caught up in what I “had to” read and know, leaving behind the secret joy of dishing out novel-length stories for a bunch of strangers on the internet.

Fanfiction is still dismissed as unserious: a guilty pleasure at best, juvenile at worst. The judgement mirrors the way mass-market paperbacks sold in supermarkets rarely make it onto university reading lists. Even now, as a lecturer, mentioning fanfiction in academic spaces tends to prompt a slightly embarrassed laugh. “It’s a fun thing,” colleagues admit: “at least it gets young people reading.” The implication lurks beneath the surface: Fanfiction may train enthusiasm, but not skill; passion, but not literary discernment. The literary academe’s dismissal of fan-created writing is not only unimaginative, it reveals how our structures of publication, distribution, and intellectual property are entirely geared towards enshrining fiction as, above all, a product. In doing so, it doubles down on the idea that textual creativity is the domain of the lone genius who must either create an entirely original “product,” or not at all.

Fanfiction as a creative practice already assumes what any literary scholarship worth its salt must acknowledge: Narrative is a social act. It is created under, and carries the traces of, our shared experiences at any given time. When a book or television show handles trauma carelessly, or reduces female characters to plot devices, or implies queer desire only to shy away from it, fandom responds by reshaping the story. Where traditional creative writing workshops rely on clear hierarchies, genre coherence, and marketable-length works, fanfiction communities tend to play with these. There is no single authority whose judgement is final. Instead, there are beta readers, commenters, moderators, and co-authors, all contributing in different ways. Beta reading in fandom can be astonishingly rigorous; people donate hours to improving a story simply because they care about it. Many of us lecturers are hard-pressed to dedicate the same kind of time when reading and annotating a student essay, simply because we often have hundreds to handle. Studying and teaching literature can, ironically, turn out vastly less personal than soliciting feedback on your fic from thousands of strangers online.

My formative experiences of writing were not neatly composed essays for school, but long, messy, derivative stories typed late into the night on Windows XP. I was not trying to produce something original and marketable. I was trying to understand what made my favorite characters tick; what would happen if a storyline veered in a different direction; how a minor event might develop if given more attention. To write good fanfiction, one must read with a kind of mild obsession that no teacher could have forced out of me. Yes, I admit, sometimes it was a touch lust-fueled (finding older, complex characters more interesting than teenage boys comes with the territory of being an only child adultified before her time). But it was also about the lack of pressure. You don’t have to be a professional in fanfic. You don’t even have to be a native speaker of the language you write in. 

Fanfiction is still dismissed as unserious: a guilty pleasure at best, juvenile at worst.

This sort of writing encourages you to let go of what kills creativity: the need to get things “perfect.” There is a romantic myth that writing ought to be slow, painful and refined through lengthy bouts of solitary suffering. But fandom simply does not work like that. People draft huge chapters overnight, update long-running epics weekly, and experiment with new ideas. There is no pressure to be definitive, only the excitement of the story and the knowledge that readers are waiting. By the time I sat my first timed essay or faced my first academic deadline, I already knew how to write quickly and consistently without being too precious about it. The instinct to keep going, to produce imperfect work regularly, was built during those late-night writing sessions when the only reward was the joy of seeing a deluge of comments on your latest upload. This is a far cry from what I still encounter in academia: People terrified of putting a foot wrong, paralyzed by the blank page.

It’s worth asking why academia has been so reluctant to acknowledge the pedagogical value of fanfiction. The overarching reason goes back to what much does: the global economic system we are in. Fanfiction has an uneasy relationship with the concept of authorship, ownership, and monetization. Literary studies geared towards the imperatives of capitalist market values deem originality and solitary creative labors of utmost importance. It wants one name behind the product: a single mastermind who can be paraded out for book tours, signings, and conventions. This is imperative for securing intellectual property, and ensuring that everyone involved—editors, publishers, distributors—get their cut from any reuse.

Fanfiction undermines this at every point. It is derivative by design and collaborative in practice. It thrives outside commercial structures and pays no regard to copyright as a measure of legitimacy. It undermines the assumption that originality is the highest literary virtue. It isn’t driven by racking up institutional accolades, as real names are never used. It not only suggests that writing can be meaningful even when it builds directly on existing material, but it often reveals a hidden truth: No writer is an island. Storytelling is a communal, not an individual, act, even if we put one author’s name on it. Any author is inspired by countless others, and stands on the shoulders of their own favorites.

Storytelling, in other words, is an impulse, not a project. In The Dawn of Everything: A New History of Humanity, David Graeber and David Wengrow show that for tens of thousands of years, human beings created stories not for ownership, but as communal, improvisational acts. Whether oral, gestural, or written, they were passed around for pleasure and leisure. Storytelling thrived long before private ownership or the notion of literary “products.” The instinct that drove me to write fanfic as a teenager was part of this older, collective history of narrative. Fandom’s sprawling, unpaid, co-created archives are not an aberration but a digital-age continuation of something very human and very ancient.

This sort of writing encourages you to let go of what kills creativity: the need to get things ‘perfect.’

That fanfiction today proliferates without monetary compensation shows how recently we accepted the idea that creativity must be validated and enshrined through its market reception. Fandom quietly refuses all of that, and in doing so, it reveals how arbitrary those rules really are. If readers and writers can co-create meaning, what becomes of the author’s authority? If more readers resonate with a pseudonymous fic by someone with a day job instead of with a celebrity author, what becomes of the publishing world’s profit imperatives? If students learn to become good readers via fic, what of the academe’s claim to arbitrate literary value? Dismissing it altogether is easier than grappling with these large aesthetic and political questions.

Whatever the answers, fanfiction won’t go away, because it represents a radical space of literacy. It is accessible to people who might never have seen themselves as writers. It welcomes teenagers producing multi-chapter works, ESL writers experimenting bravely in another language, queer writers reshaping narrative worlds that have excluded them, neurodivergent writers finding safety in anonymity where formal classrooms failed them. There are no fees, no prerequisites, no admissions processes; you don’t know an author’s race, income or gender. It is a comparatively level playing field that reminds us we are driven to creative labor because we are human, whether or not financial compensation enters the picture.

Fandom taught me to pay attention, to question the politics of authorship, and to dare venture into the heavily classed and raced sphere of literary criticism without imposter syndrome. It gave me a version of literary culture that was unafraid of passion and unembarrassed about the pleasures of the imagination. And despite the distance between my current job title and that sixteen-year-old me hunched over a keyboard late at night, I am certain that everything I value about literature began in those early, communal, online spaces. Rediscovering my own fics reminded me that the most meaningful literary communities are still the ones built outside institutions: messy, irreverent, unprofitable, and utterly alive.

15 Small Press Books You Don’t Want to Miss This Winter

I’m writing this on the last day of 2025, knowing it won’t run until early 2026—and it’s the weird limbo time, where everything is “Best of” looking backwards or predictions of what 2026 might bring, looking forward. 

If the books on this list are any indication, novellas are having a bit of a moment, collections of short stories just keep getting better, and hybrid memoir needs a new name (anyone have an idea?) because it feels like it’s a genre completely unto its own rather than a mashup. What emerges as a theme is secrets: long-buried or exposed, obscured or open. Amnesia makes a man forget the secrets he is keeping from his wife; a war-time wife takes on boarders without telling her husband, reveling in the community and freedom; a morgue worker in Maoist China has a secret pet. We all know that secrets have a way, like water, of finding cracks to seep through. This is the case for many of the books below. No matter what we try to hide, information comes out. 

In 2026, I have my own small-press published book coming out, and it has been a reminder of how many generous readers, writers, and editors work in this industry. Now more than ever, it feels vital to support the work of independent presses who operate in a media landscape driven by ideas and inquiry, rather than units sold.

If your New Year’s resolution is to read more books, the below is a great starting point. 

Whiskey Tit: More Hell by Adam Al-Sirgany

A young woman plays French horn in the community college band, second chair to her abusive boyfriend; a machinist at the oat factory always has an open door for punk and jam-band loving twenty-somethings; a seven-year-old boy scrapes his hand against a family-friend’s lead painted siding. In More Hell, al-Sirgany does more than offer a tour of the Midwest: He makes the region real. These stories take place on dirt roads and in houses with rattling screen doors, in bars and apartments surrounded by farmland. Even if one is not from the rural nor the Midwest, these stories carry a sense of a homeplace, with all of the complications that come along with it. Compelling and written with both a twist-the-knife pain and compress-the-wound empathy. 

Rescue Press: Hurricane Envy by Sara Jaffe

In this collection of short stories, Sara Jaffe quietly but powerfully explores music, longing, families, disasters. A mother brings her baby into a bar in the middle of the day to have seltzer and French fries and a brief respite from the isolation of motherhood; a young man is rejected from a college but moves to the town anyway, where he tries to connect with the music scene while figuring out what shape his life is going to take; a writer is assigned to write for a gallery and is relieved when it doesn’t work out. Her stories have range, but often come back to a pivotal moment. Hurricane Envy does what the best do, which is to leave readers satisfied with each story while still wanting more. Read one of the stories in Recommended Reading!

Tin House: The Salvage by Anbara Salam

Against the backdrop of the Cuban Missile Crisis of 1962, elite diver and marine archeologist Marta Khoury is in Cairnroch, an isolated island in the frigid east coast of Scotland. While she is immensely suited to explore the wreckage of a Victorian-era ship captained by one of the island’s own, Marta also has a connection to the island and a tragic death that occurred on its shores. The Salvage strikes a balance between the specifics of Marta’s profession and the sometimes petty dramas of the island’s residents, while also exploring both her own personal stakes in salvaging items from the wreck and her certainty that she’s seen a shadowy figure lurking around the ship on her dives. The Salvage is an adventurous book with emotional resonance. 

Cornerstone Press: Western Terminus by Michael Keefe 

In this collection of stories and a novella, Michael Keefe takes readers through the cracked dry landscape of the American West and Southwest, riding in pickup trucks and station wagons in search of family, belonging, and answers. In one story, a family leaves their patriarch after a vacation gone wrong. In another, a man returns to his family home with a nagging suspicion his father was involved in a farm worker’s death, and his attempt to unearth old family secrets uncovers something new about himself—and a revelation about his father. The men of Keefe’s stories don’t always find what they are searching for, but they take the reader along for a glorious ride. 

IG Publishing: A Complete Fiction by R.L. Maizes

Tapping into a deep fear for writers, aspiring-author P.J. Larkin is convinced editor George Dunn has stolen the novel she submitted to him and takes to social media to call him out. Soon, Dunn is snagged in what looks like a scandal, and Larkin and her manuscript are a hot commodity—but she’s beginning to face her own controversy around the content. A Complete Fiction captures the contemporary anxiety of what is private and what is public through a narrative that has its finger on the pulse of social media’s amplifying power. While this novel is asking big questions about cancel culture, appropriation of stories, and what it means to make art in the internet age, it’s also very funny. Maizes gives us a book that is compulsively readable. 

SFWP: Bitter Over Sweet by Melissa Llanes Brownlee

Outside of the beachy resorts and tourist luaus, Hawaiian natives like Tita are living their actual lives, not vacation: there are bills to pay, abusive boyfriends, handsy bosses, uncles who beat a niece for kissing another girl. There are also cold beers overlooking Kona, drives along rocky lava-paved roads, poi made from scratch. In this collection of flash and short fictions, Llanes Brownlee writes with precision and deft contrast: the taste of salt could be from shear off of the sea, or from blood. The narrative has nuance, but also punch. Tita is in many ways more than just one person, and has more than just one story. Bitter Over Sweet is an excellent entry from a new voice in fiction. 

Dzanc Books: Coydog by David Tromblay

After a long stint in the Army and a tour in Desert Storm, Moses Kincaid, of the Wisconsin Ho-Chunk tribe, becomes a bounty hunter based out of Kansas City who has found himself chasing a wanted man through Oklahoma. It’s not just the cops who want Eric Drumgoole, it’s also the members of a notorious motorcycle gang. When a diner waitress offers to help him, the two quickly become more than friends. Yet, Kincaid is in a rough trade, and he and the people around him are snared in violence. Coydog follows Kindcaid as he tries to do his job, which fundamentally means operating in a gray area. He’s as tough as they come, but his hypervigilance also belies the trauma of his past. Tromblay’s novel is just as heavy on plot as it is on the heart.

Eastover Press: A Stranger Comes to Town by Lynne Sharon Schwartz

Joe Marzino, a well-known television actor, awakes in the hospital with no memory. Out jogging, he was knocked unconscious by a bicyclist. As he’s filled in about the details of the accident—and the life he was living—nothing sparks recognition. Yet, as Joe is discharged, with physically nothing wrong other than a nasty ankle sprain, amnesia has given him no context to know the family that surrounds him. With no reason to suspect anything other than what he is told, he plays the part of the loving husband and father. Yet, as fragments of memory return and living his day-to-day surfaces the man he was before the accident, the very obvious before and after of a penultimate life event takes on an ever deeper meaning. Lynne Sharon Schwartz brings her mastery of characterization to this new novel and offers a moving story of new beginnings.

Rose Metal Press: Fit Into Me by Molly Gaudry

Informed by the author’s own recovery from a traumatic brain injury, Fit Into Me is a hybrid memoir with a novel tucked into its center. The speaker swims, the speaker does voice therapy, the speaker writes, the speaker recovers. It’s meta-memoir, auto-fictional, and packed with literary allusions (many explained in footnotes). The structure—both fragmented and coherent, like a mosaic or a quilt—mirrors Gaudry’s own intellectual state. There are touchstones in this book that lovers of literature will relate to, like the pure joy of discovering wonderful sentences and challenging ideas while reading, and Gaudry offers many of her own. Fit Into Me ultimately emerges as less of an experiment in form and more of an inevitable outcome. Brilliantly nuanced and forcefully written. 

OR Books: Hitler and My Mother-In-Law by Terese Svoboda

In this memoir, the inciting action is trying to confirm the authenticity of a photo where Svoboda’s mother-in-law, the trailblazing journalist Pat Lochridge, is pointing at Hitler’s ashes. Yet, the book is more than verifying one historical artifact. Svoboda and her husband, despite excavating their basement files, can’t find the original image, and alongside the story of the photograph is the story of how Lochridge ended up becoming part of Svoboda’s family. The book threads the mythology of Lochridge, the backdrops of war, and the writing work they share as a profession, with Svoboda’s own professional and personal history. There is a gentle distance between the women—not as rivalries, and nothing as boring as in-law conflict—but a nuance of generations and circumstances. The memoir is meticulously researched and thoughtful when looking at the past. This is Svoboda at the height of her power as a writer.

7.13 Books: The Morgue Keeper by Ruyan Meng

In 1966, during the Cultural Revolution in China, Qing Yuan works alongside his colleagues, others who have been conscripted as workers in a morgue. The delivery of dead bodies is constant, and the men become numb to violence. The work is gruesome, but they are fed, housed, and spared the so-called reeducation camps. Yet, when a badly beaten body, labeled #19, crosses Quin Yuan’s table and no one comes to claim her, he is thrust into a search to understand who she was. Searching for information about #19 defies the Mao regime, and it is in this defiance that Qing Yuan finds moments of joy and connection. The Morgue Keeper is a compelling story of compassion and quiet resistance. 

Autumn House: The Great Grown-Up Game of Make-Believe by Lauren D. Woods

Teenagers fantasize about moving into a neighborhood house while coyotes terrorize the surrounding area; a young man working at a rental car call center to provide for his young child gets fired; a woman goes through a year of managing a break-up. In this collection, Woods deeply explores loss and what it means in the moment and its immediate aftermath, the personally-specific ways we imbue meaning to the everyday as we search for answers, and how grief shapes the future. Magical realism and fluidity of form make the collection all the more poignant. The Great Grown-Up Game of Make Believe is one of those rare debut story collections that grabs the reader by the throat and does not let go. 

Regal House: If You Leave by Margaret Hutton

Before he is shipped off to WWII, Audrey and Ben marry in a rush. She works a wartime job cataloging film in Washington D.C. and is called toward being a visual artist. He is a surgeon in the Navy living in his childhood home after the passing of his mother, and Audrey joins him there before his deployment, surrounded by the belongings of a dead woman and a man she hardly knows. While Ben is deployed, Audrey takes in two boarders—Lucille, pregnant and hiding it, and Daniel, who she feels drawn to—both of whom change her life in different ways. This is a novel split into befores and afters, with a deception at its center. Hutton writes deftly about how secrets find a way out into the light, with both relief and consequences jumbling together.

McSweeney’s: Martha’s Daughter by David Haynes

In these stories set across Texas, Missouri, Minnesota, and an unnamed city in the South, a young Black couple looks for the owner of a run-over cat in a white neighborhood; a woman chooses to marry a man she finds boring in order to avoid drama, only to have trouble stirred up years later; and in the title novella, Cynthia (Martha’s daughter) works through her complicated relationship to her mother with an overbearing co-worker in tow. While often somewhat situationally absurd, Hayne’s pinpointed prose keeps readers completely in the moment. A stunning, accomplished collection perfect for fans of Haynes or readers new to his oeuvre. 

Sibylinne Press: The House of Cavanaugh by Polly Dugan

In 1989, as Joan Cavanaugh is dying from cancer at only forty-eight, she begins to recount and take stock of her life. At the center of her story is a secret she is determined to take to her grave: Twenty-five years earlier, she had an affair, and when it ended, she returned to her husband and three young daughters pregnant. Another twenty-five years later, though Joan has long been gone, a chance encounter and modern twist—the genetic test—exposes her. The House of Cavanaugh takes a fresh look at the age-old family concern of paternity, including tackling how families have been upended by easy-to-access DNA kits. Dugan turns the premise into an explosive and satisfying novel.

Surviving My Assault Means Understanding Where, and Who, I Come From

Editor’s note: This essay deals with topics of childhood sexual assault, rape, and incest.

“Hush” by Torie Rose Wiley

The Armless Maiden, or in some retellings, The Maiden Without Hands, is an ancient folktale that has been passed down throughout different cultures and generations. In the older versions, a young girl lives alone with her brother, until one day, he tries to marry her. The girl refuses, and the brother severs both of her arms as punishment. He kicks the girl out of their home, forcing her to live amongst the animals in the forest. Without her arms, the girl is unable to pick fruit from the trees to feed herself. She cannot climb. She cannot touch. She is unable to bathe, to hold herself when her body shivers, to make something with her hands.

In later versions, the incest is eliminated from the story. Instead, the girl’s brother or father removes her arms in a desperate act to save themselves from the Devil. In later versions, they take her hands, not her arms. In even later versions, they ask the girl if they can cut off her hands, and she agrees. 


Everytime my cousin, F, molests me, our family is close by, often in the same room. The first time, he and I are both sitting in the backseat of my father’s car. K, my sister, is in the front, and my dad is driving us all home from a haunted house. He laughs as he pushes and rubs his hands against my arms, my ribs, my thighs. Do you know what pressure points are, he asks as he presses a finger into the divet of my shoulder, sending a rush of pain throughout my body. He keeps touching, pushing harder against my skin, like he’s trying to peel me open and consume what’s inside. My dad right there, my sister right there. They don’t say anything as F shoves his hands and face into my lap. I’m so cold, you need to help warm me up, he says. I am ten. 

Another time, K and F’s younger brother are laying in the same bed as us watching a movie. F drags his hand against my inner thigh under the blanket. Yet another time, F’s mom pulls him into her room, screaming at him after she catches him picking open the lock to her bathroom door while I’m inside.

Each time, I tell myself he will realize he is hurting me and stop on his own. I tell myself I’m being dramatic, like when I tell my mom my feet are going to fall off from walking so much at the zoo. He hasn’t raped me, wouldn’t rape me, I think. Rape only happens in dark alleys with strangers. God will make sure he stops before it ever gets to that. I attend catechism school once a week. My cousin is an altar boy. We have to be safe, being so close to God. Someone will save me. 

He rapes me on Thanksgiving, two years after it all started. I am twelve. Our entire family is a floor above us as he first plunges his hand into the slushy, stained beer cooler, then into the part of me that only I had ever touched. I feel the heat of my mother and grandmother’s laughter and hear the clink of knives to plates as he plucks me from my body, leaving me to rot.

After, as we sit around the table with our family, I feel the sour, acidic breath of death pushing against my face. I feel the lack of distance. The awareness that he will never stop. The old, animal parts of me that know how to spot a predator tell me that next time, he will eat me. 


When asked if there are any shared beliefs throughout cultures, an anthropology professor I take a course with in college replies, adamantly, that there are no universal truths. There is no consistent way of being human that permeates all communities and bloodlines. However, he adds, the taboos of cannibalism and incest are the closest we get. 

The word incest derives from the Latin words for not—in and chaste—castus. The word denotes impurity. To be associated with incest is to be cut off or severed from wholeness.

Dissolved boundaries. Sisters as wives. Cousins as rapists. The people who made you are the same ones to take you apart. 

I tell Mom a few weeks after my cousin rapes me, just before Christmas. 


Some people were put on this earth to follow, others to lead—I was put here to lead. My grandmother often repeats when asked about her domineering nature. 

I feel the heat of my mother and grandmother’s laughter and hear the clink of knives to plates as he plucks me from my body, leaving me to rot.

When she was born, rape was not considered a federal crime. Rape by a husband was considered a happenstance part of marriage—a husband’s right to claim as he pleased. A woman or girl had to prove she actively resisted in order for a jury of white men to call it rape. Within the Catholic Church, my teenage grandmother is taught that any birth control method is immoral. Divorce is immoral. Women are expected to uphold a pure, modest image—no matter what. 

But as a kid, I don’t know my grandmother as this woman. I know her as the woman who dances with me to All I Want For Christmas Is You in the middle of summer because it is my favorite song. 

By day as a city councilwoman, unbeknownst to kid-me, my grandmother bobs and weaves her way through town regulations, tax laws, and men with armpit stains in their suits. By night, she makes me easy-mac while we watch reruns of Franklin in our matching saddlebag-red leather recliners. I am her youngest granddaughter, and I own my role. I study how me in tutus and sequins and lipstick and pink make her eyes lighten. How she tells Mom I will absolutely not be wearing pants to kindergarten. 

Anytime she takes me out to eat, someone knows her and comes up to the table to talk to her. Mom, father, both aunts, uncles—likely others who I am not even aware of—all gain full-time, secure jobs at public schools or departments via the good word of my grandmother. She keeps everyone in line. One time, she screamed at Mom for twenty minutes because there was a dryer sheet underneath a chair in our living room. I swear, I didn’t even see it until I laid down on the fuzzy green carpet and went looking for it. Nothing gets past her. Our family has an image to uphold. 


When I’m born, rape is defined in the same way it was when my grandmother and mother were born. Carnal knowledge of a female, forcibly and against her will. Carnal knowledge. As if a body is a tempting fruit full of forbidden truths. As if one can get to the core of a person by forcing teeth though skin.

Between my birth and my rape, we get two dogs: a black and white, ornery collie mix named Susie, and an ever-hungry black lab named Macie. I watch SpongeBob and The Amanda Show with my older sisters. Mom tries to get me to wear eye patches to correct my lazy eye, but I insist on peeling it off as soon as she looks away. I write my first book: a stapled, paper booklet about fire-breathing cats and dogs. CPS comes—I find out as an adult it’s because my sister, K, told her high school guidance counselor that Mom took two Jell-O shots before driving with my sister, me, and a few of our friends in the backseat. I tell CPS I only see Mom drink every once in a while and hope they don’t find her wine bottles hidden in the Purina dog kibble bag. 

My nose bleeds. My skin blotches red, something I later learn is called eczema. Mom slathers me with cold lotion twice a day to try and make the itch go away. I pick—scabs, nails, hair, eyes, nose, teeth, lips, throat, feet, hands, elbows, knees, thighs—anywhere I can get a nail under. I don’t understand why having scabs is “bad” until years later when I go to shave for the first time and realize I can’t pull the razor up any part of my leg without ripping one open.

My older sister, K, fights back whenever Mom calls us stupid or pinches our skin until it bruises. To kid-me, K is some fearless gladiator going up against a lion, and I am some cheering bystander hoping the lion doesn’t come my way. When Mom gets mad, she bares teeth. We are no longer her children, we are idiot, lazy, selfish, worthless, bitch. 

Although K’s boldness invigorates me, I also hear the way she cries after each fight is done. After the CPS worker leaves, and Mom and K finish fighting, I tap on K’s door to see if she wants to play Xbox with me. I didn’t know he would report it, she confesses to me in broken sobs. I would never have said anything if I’d known he’d report it. I bring Mom a Sugar Daddy lollipop, her favorite, to help her calm down. I think of the time she told me to tell her if she ever started acting like her Mom, my grandmother, because she never wants to put my sisters and me through what she went through. I was too afraid to tell her she was too late. 

Besides Mom, my grandma has two other daughters, both of whom have several children. I spend every holiday, birthday, vacation, graduation, Communion, Super Bowl with my maternal grandmother, aunts, uncles, and cousins. My cousins are there the first time my feet feel the ocean. My uncle pulls splinters from my fingers so gently it never hurts. When she invites me over around Halloween, my aunt makes sure to hide any skeletons because she knows even the cute Hallmark ones make me cry.

When my grandmother is pregnant, her fetus’s ovaries hold all the eggs it will ever have. I think of Mom and I, my sisters, my aunts, my cousins. All there. Growing between her leaves.


Mom, can we talk? I say from the kitchen doorway. I had been laying on the couch, turning ornaments over between trembling fingers, waiting for the sound of cups and plates hitting cupboard shelves to indicate Mom was almost done with the dishes. 

She pauses at the sound of my words. We didn’t ever talk in my family. When I first went through puberty a few years before, she came home one day to me crying on the bathroom floor, howling about how there had been blood in my underwear, and how I was dying. There were no conversations, no sex talk, only a book on puberty left on my bed the next day. I learned I had something called a vagina when the book told me I did.

 I’ll be there in a minute, she eventually replies. My face remains stoic, not wanting to give anything away, despite the growing hum in my bones. I walk the creaky hallway down to Mom’s bedroom. A painting I made in preschool hangs up on the wall above her nightstand: a bouquet made up of my tiny preschool hands and feet. I choose to tell Mom here, rather than in my room across the hall, because something about telling her underneath my mermaid princess canopy feels worse. 

It was like I was about to tell her I had murdered somebody. Like I was about to murder my entire family in a matter of words. Will she yell at me for not telling her sooner? Will she believe me? What if she believes me but does nothing about it? Mom raised me to understand that the same hands who cut the crust off your peanut butter and jelly sandwiches and place it on your favorite Zoo Pals plate can also drag you across the hardwood floor like a piece of luggage. How do I tell the first person to ever hurt my body that I need her to stop someone else from hurting my body?

I need to tell you something. I speak between shortening breaths. Please don’t be mad. Her face sharpens. I suck in my last breath of air before forcing my tongue to speak for what feels like the first and final time.

 For the last two years, F has been touching me. 

She freezes.

Touching you how? Where?

He once—one time he lifted my shirt and put his hands and mouth on my chest and he, he—my carefully planned details boil over into babbling sobs. My body had condensed two years of terror into clear words. Now all the words it had swallowed to keep me safe were pouring out as wet noise. 

She stands up and grabs her phone.

What are you doing? I manage to squeak out. I can feel the rope of my secret slipping through my fingers, ripping skin as it pulls.

Calling my sister. F’s mom. 

Any initial relief that had started blooming quickly becomes a numbing panic. Snot sticks to the back of my throat, making my voice sound sticky. No, no, please don’t. Please don’t call her. Please—I can’t. I don’t want her to know. She can’t know. My body springs up, blood coursing with adrenaline, terrified. I wonder if F’s dad owns a gun.

A high school boy lifting up the shirt of a twelve year old girl—I’m calling her. She walks into her attached bathroom and shuts the door. 

My body heaves. I crumble onto my mom’s floor, into the stained, vomit-green dog bed beside her nightstand. What if they don’t believe me? Why did I need to tell her? What if they kill me?

Before telling her, I could picture my family reacting however I wanted. I imagined my grandma calling me, sobbing, telling me she was so sorry. I let myself dream of my uncles and aunts driving right over to hug me and take me for ice cream or movies or whatever else a raped child needs. Now, there is no pretending. 

They know. 

I think of the violent military videos showing people melting into pieces that F would often make me watch because he thought they were funny. I think of the way he and his dad often bought collectible weapons—grenades, swords, rifles, knives, tasers—and kept them in the basement beside F’s room. I should have just let him keep raping me

He said it only happened once. Mom speaks as she walks back into the room. She was probably only gone for minutes, but to me, every second of her not running up and holding me and telling me she still loved me was too long. 

We stare into each other. Her, looking to see if I’m worth losing her family over. Me, looking to her to tell me I am. 

Finally, she exhales. What do you need

Courtrooms flash before my eyes. Police. Scary, adult words like testimony and witness and evidence. It would be my word against his. He was tall, blonde-haired with light eyes. I was lanky, and the Clearasil that was supposed to help with my acne had just turned the hair around my face an acidic yellow. His parents built him a basketball court in their backyard, while my parents had just spent the last year getting divorced. And really, I didn’t want to see how many people sat on his side over mine. I couldn’t handle any more hurt.

I don’t ever want to see him again. I eventually speak.

Then you never will.


After the Armless Maiden is left to die in the woods by her brother, a prince eventually finds her and brings her back to his kingdom. He falls in love with the armless girl after seeing how persistent and strong she is. They marry and have a baby. Years pass. One day while the prince is away, the girl’s brother hears of her new life. Livid, he sends a letter to the king and queen pretending to be the prince. He tricks them into believing the prince is horrified at the ugliness of their baby and wants the girl banished back to the forest, where she belongs. The king and queen reluctantly obey what they think are their son’s wishes, abandoning the armless girl in the woods with her baby strapped to her back.

So much can be stolen. 


When my grandmother learns that my cousin sexually abused me, she tells Mom that he and I should sit down and talk it out. Mom refuses, but she continues making me see my grandmother.

It would be my word against his. He was tall, blonde-haired with light eyes.

You have to be understanding, Torie. She’s his grandmother, too. She wants to see you. It’ll just be you, her, and your other cousins. F won’t be there, Mom argues one morning after my grandmother asks to take my other cousins and me to lunch. She doesn’t want to pick sides, I’m told, whenever I ask Mom why grandma always brings us leftover cake from his house. If she doesn’t want to pick sides, why does she always go to his house first on holidays? Why doesn’t he get leftover cake?

My aunts don’t want to pick sides, either. Or my uncles. I see a few of them for a couple of short visits after I tell Mom, and then I never see them again, except for the Facebook photos showing everyone huddled around F for Christmas each year after.

No one ever asks me what happened. As a child, and now, I want them to know what happened. 

Toward the end of lunch, my other cousins both go use the bathroom before we leave. My grandmother and I sit alone for the first time since I told Mom about the abuse.

So tell me how you’ve been. Your mom has you doing therapy?

I go once a week. I answer as I pick the ends off my French fries and start a pile next to my chicken nuggets for all the pieces that are too crunchy. 

Good. Good. She wipes her mouth with her napkin and leans back in her chair. F has been seeing a therapist, too. 

That’s good, I—

—hush, here come your cousins.

I take my cue and swallow the questions my body ached to ask. Why don’t you ask me about what he did? Why didn’t you call me the night you found out? What do I need? Why do you care more about him than me? How can you still stomach seeing him? How could you see every speck of dust Mom missed and not once see what he was doing to me? How—

Hush.


This is how the months following my disclosure go. Slivers of moments where my body pauses for a sip of air before swallowing more and more and more and more and more words. I feel something kicking inside me, needing to come out, and I keep telling it we need to wait for the right time. 

How did therapy go? Mom asks every week while she drives me home. Good, I always reply, not sure how to tell her that talking to a stranger for an hour a week isn’t really helping. I ask the therapist questions like, do you think I’ll end up hurting people like my cousin? while opening another one of the Dove chocolates from her candy bowl. 

At school, no one knows. 

Just after my birthday, I dislocate my kneecap. It’s before homeroom, and my friends and I are all talking at the back of the class when my best friend kicks my leg out from under me. I think she underestimates how hard her kick is, or overestimates how sturdy my leg is. Either way, there is now a divot where my kneecap used to be, and an orchestra of pain rips at my leg. I scream so loud, one boy brings me a brownie the next day because he says the noises that came out of my mouth gave him nightmares. 

Between the screams and convulsions running up and down my leg, I worry for my friend. What will happen to her if they find out she kicked me? I had seen the pale look on her face before Mr. M rushed her and everyone else out of the classroom so the paramedics could come. I know she didn’t mean to hurt me. So when the paramedics, the principal, and Mom ask me what happened, I tell them I had just slipped on a book bag and fell the wrong way. 

Did I lie to protect my friend because that’s just what kids do for their friends? Or did I do it because the rape led me to believe that my friend would leave me if I was honest about how she had hurt me? Or maybe because Mom raised me to think I need to comfort someone after they hurt me. I no longer have my family to look toward when I wonder who I will become, where I come from, who I am. Which parts of me are mine? 

Sometimes when I get home from school, I find a book on my bed from Mom that somehow deals with rape or sexual abuse. Once, I call a friend to read her a scene from The Lovely Bones—one of the books Mom leaves me. 

Don’t read that—Mom scolds after she must have heard me reading through my bedroom door and opened it sharply. Don’t read those to your friends. 

At parties, Mom asks me if it’s okay to tell her friend, or in some cases, a stranger, about F molesting me. It usually happens after someone asks Mom how her family is doing.

Can I tell them? she asks as the adults around us all stare at me. 

Yeah, sure, I respond each time. You took her family away from her, you owe her this, some voice in the back of my mind tells me. I guess she doesn’t want to lie, which part of me appreciates, but I can’t understand why she is allowed to talk about my abuse whenever she wants, but when I try to, it’s never the right time.


The worst, for me, happens at the beach less than a year after I tell Mom. It’s August, and Mom has recently married my stepdad. For their honeymoon, they take my younger stepsister, N, and me to the beach for a week. K is at home watching our pets. I’m thirteen. 

N and I are sitting next to each other in beach chairs, feet sunk in the warm sand, when she taps my shoulder to have me take out my headphones. 

Did you hear any of what they said? N asks. Our parents had just left for a walk down the shore. 

No, what?

She hesitates. 

Your grandmother took K to lunch. She invited your aunt without telling her. My jaw cinches. They both tried to convince K to make you see F. They said you probably asked him to do it, that you wanted the attention. 

I watch as a dad bobs his baby up and down through waves along the shoreline a little ahead of us. I can’t stop the words from running out of me.

What did K say?

No one wants to pick sides. I can’t trust that my sister will defend me anymore. I can’t trust anyone.

She left the restaurant after telling them to go fuck themselves, N replies.

Oh.

I wish I could say my sister’s words rang strong in my ears, but I was more focused on blaming myself for her being in a situation where she even had to defend me in the first place. My needing to tell Mom that I was being abused caused my sister to face yet another fight—is how I saw it then. She shouldn’t protect me anymore. Nobody should protect me. I don’t want anyone else to hurt. 

When K got home, N continues, your cousin, F, sent her an email telling her she should kill herself.

I’m thirteen when I’m convinced that my words are only good for hurting the people I have left.


Sometime years later, while Mom pours herself another glass of wine at our kitchen table, she starts talking about my grandmother. I think her grandfather, your great great grandfather, may have raped her when she was younger. She never told me he did—but there was a weird feeling I would get when he was around her, when she would talk about him. She lived with him for most of her childhood. She says it with a casual sort of ease. My stomach hardens. 

She continues as she takes another bite of her food, there was something always off with her. She was never a mother to me. When I was four—just four years old, a baby—she let me walk around the neighborhood with our cat on a leash. One day, a stray dog came up and attacked us. I didn’t know what to do, so I just held on to the cat for dear life as we both screamed. I don’t remember all of it, but I remember dragging the cat home after it was dead. No one was watching me. Her voice breaks as she takes another sip of wine. I stare down, having heard her tell this story many times before, still having no sense of what to say. You should be grateful to have a mom like me.

I try to understand what all of it means, if anything. Why the possibility of my grandmother having also been molested only makes me feel worse. How I hate the thought of my mother walking along that street alone. How I’m anything but grateful. How I’m terrified of what I come from, of who I will become. 

I can’t trust that my sister will defend me anymore. I can’t trust anyone.

I wish I could give back my blood and start over as someone who didn’t inherit such violence. I wish I could go back and save my grandmother and mother from all that pain. But whenever I get close to some sense of clarity through the fog, I always end up instead at the same question, the one that unravels me all over again—why didn’t they save me?

I later confirm with census records that yes, my grandmother did live in a home with her grandfather for several years. I also found that her grandmother alternated between living in that house and a room in a mental asylum for three decades. 

Mom tells me that most, if not all, of our Irish-Catholic ancestors were poor. The women in my family had many children during the decades prior to birth control, and many more in the decades since. One gives birth to 16 children, only eight of whom survive past four.

Another works 16-hour days twisting buttons onto pocketbooks she will never afford at a since-abandoned factory in our hometown. 

Several attempt suicide.

It’s like they each were the heir to some thick, aching hunger. 

Maybe he did. Maybe it’s enough to know that it could’ve happened, that my grandmother and great great grandmother and every grandmother before them could have been raped and stayed silent because somewhere along the way, someone convinced them that that’s the only way to heal. Maybe it’s enough that the stories of their lives died with them, leaving anyone to fill in gaps as they see fit.


We stop talking to my grandmother and the rest of my extended family after getting home from the beach.

Before the beach, I write 10-page book reports when the teacher only requires one. My friends and I tell each other our biggest secrets, like how we once ate paper, or how we once cut our own hair, or that time we flushed a lollipop stick down the toilet at a hotel and it flooded an entire hallway. Teachers toss paper balls at us to get us to stop talking in class. Once while jumping on the trampoline in my backyard, I tell a joke so good, my friend pees herself from laughing. And instead of crying or gagging or trying to pretend it’s not her pee that’s pooling into the center of the trampoline, we jump even harder. Before, words are my rhythm, my power, my love. 

After the beach, words are hard, wretched things. How’s your grandma been? my dentist asks after she tells me to rinse and spit, and I scrounge up and mash the words together to lie: she’s okay. A friend comes up to me in the library at school and says, your cousin, A, just told everyone at lunch that you’re an asshole, and I whip the words, oh, weird, I’m not sure why he said that, until they collapse out of my mouth. When my aunt comes up to me at a science fair in front of all my friends with a big smile on her face and asks, how ya been? I drag the words, I’ve been good, it’s nice to see you! by the scalp until they get in line and sound convincing. After, words scatter when they hear me calling. 

Years pass, I don’t write, or read, and sometimes when people touch me, I don’t feel it. 

Years pass, I convince myself everything is over, it’s done, then Mom is diagnosed with early-stage breast cancer, and a few days later, we receive a letter from my grandmother saying: my prayers have been answered. Like Mom being alive and well is the only reason our family is broken. 

I wish I could go back and save my grandmother and mother from all that pain.

Years pass, then my boyfriend joins our high school crew team, and my cousin, F, is a coach. We argue after he tells me he only talked to F because he was being polite, and he asks if I was sure I didn’t want my cousin to abuse me, and I don’t break up with him on the spot. In fact, I date him for another few years. 

Years pass, I’m in highschool when I hear someone on the news say Christine Blasey Ford only accused Brett Kavanaugh of rape because she wants the attention, and I hear my stepfather say the same thing about another woman who accused an actor of rape, and I tell him, you know when you say that, you’re talking about me, right? and he says, of course I’m not talking about you, this has nothing to do with you, and he has this solid look on his face that tells me he really doesn’t see how this has everything to do with me.

Years pass, then F sends me twenty-two Facebook messages in a row saying he did it because he was curious/spoiled/rotten, saying he wakes up once a week with nightmares, saying it must be worse for me, saying it’s up to us to fix our family, saying he will kill himself if I want him to, saying punish me and not my family, saying it will only be too late once grandma is dead, and I’m sitting in my high school English class wondering if I should answer him or scream or call Mom or run to the bathroom and slap my face with sink water until I stop crying, or swallow it.

I stay in class and swallow it. 

Years pass, then I go home and tell Mom he messaged me today, and she won’t stop chopping that onion she was chopping, and I tell myself she must not have heard the break in my voice. 

Years pass and years pass and years pass, and suddenly I am twenty years old, my grandmother is dead, and I am forced to reckon with the fact that I cannot outrun what I come from. 


My eyes pick through the list of names in my grandmother’s obituary until they find mine among the pile of estranged relatives. The deepest parts of me buckle. My lungs squeeze and stretch, squeeeeze and stretch, until I hack up globs of sticky, fat mucus. My body tries to evacuate from me, or me from it. We’re past this, stop crying, I tell myself as I go to the bathroom to flush down the chunky soup of snot and spit. Even though I have not seen or spoken to the matrilineal side of my family in eight years, my name is still there—next to the cousin who raped me.

It’s the smell of incense. The high ceiling of a Catholic Church. Ice against skin. Cracks in a leather couch. Normal, everyday things that once held no power, now are artifacts for my rape. Echoes from a past life. I see his name next to mine, and my twenty-year-old body feels the same way it did when it was twelve. Past and present fold into one beneath my skin. 

I convinced myself that my grandmother would eventually send me a letter saying something to the effect of: I’m so sorry. I wasn’t there for you when you needed me. I love you. She must realize she’s wrong one day—right? As people called out Harvey Weinstein and R. Kelly and Bill Cosby and Brock Turner and Jeffrey Epstein and Larry Nassar throughout the Me Too movement, I waited for my letter to come. I thought, it would be so much easier now, she has to do it. I pictured her watching the news, reading the newspapers, perhaps checking out a memoir or two from the library. She’d listen to all those stories, really listen, and realize, like I had, that my cousin was the wrong one, not me. She’d realize how much damage she caused by silencing me, by minimizing me, by blaming me. She’d set things right before she went, give me what I needed to heal, tell me I can shout my truth from her rooftop if I wanted to. Deathbed confessions and all that. 

But now—she’s dead. I can no longer hang on to the caricature of her in my head. Even in the face of death, there is no letter. No wordcrumbs for me to use to convince myself that my life of lying and suppressing is enough to keep me full. My grandmother dies content enough in her erasure of me that she didn’t feel any need to try and repair it. 

I do not know how she dies, and I still do not talk to anyone who would know. 

She tells me I know what he did, and I’m the only witness I’ll ever need.

For the first time, I picture my future, Me in ten, twenty, fifty years, and I know that I could die still waiting for someone to come and make me whole. I see her. I see myself. She’s spent her life lying and pretending to protect other’s peace at the expense of her own. She doesn’t write. There is a hollowness that grows in her every time she talks to someone, a great, big rot that tells her she’ll do nothing but disgust them if she gets too close. I see it radiating from within her. So much can be stolen. 

Then, she cups my face in her hands, smiling, keeping me there, safe. Breathing. Sitting there, my head between her hard, wrinkled palms that shine from my tears, she tells me none of this was ever my fault. She tells me I know what he did, and I’m the only witness I’ll ever need. She tells me she’s sorry my grandmother and mother hurt me in so many moments where they could’ve helped me grow. She tells me she’s sorry they’re too hurt to love me the way I need. She tells me I am capable of living my whole life without ever remembering who I am, just as they are. Or, she tells me, I can reclaim my truth. I can live the life we deserve. 

To heal, she tells me, I need to understand where I come from, so I better understand where I can go. I need to name all that was taken from me, so I can know all that will never be. 

In the forest, the Armless Maiden is devastated. When no one can see her, she weeps. With her baby strapped to her back, she worries about how she will feed either of them. What type of life will they live in the wilderness? While kneeling down to drink from a nearby river, the baby kicks, and the girl stumbles, causing the baby to fall into the water. The girl dives in after her baby, and, without thinking, she reaches out to find him, to bring him back to her. She is surprised when two long, strong, arms emerge from her shoulders and catch her baby with ease. How did her arms come back? A river spirit? A God? The Maiden does not know the answers to all her questions, but as she cradles her baby, she knows she has everything she will ever need. No one can take this from her. She is whole.

In the months after my grandmother’s death, I let myself live. I make something with my hands. I start writing my truth.

Evangelical Purity Culture Affects Us All

In the opening of Anna Rollins’ debut memoir, Famished: On Food, Sex, and Growing Up a Good Girl, Rollins is in the ICU with a sick child, but all she can think about is how she’s going to work off the pasta she’d eaten the night before. At the time, Rollins “knew it was a coping mechanism . . . what you’ve done your whole life to distract yourself from anything that feels out of control or scary,” as she told me, but conversely, she felt guilt: for being a working mom, for putting her son in daycare. At that moment it became clear to Rollins, who told me, “There’s so much bound up in this [disordered eating] and I want to be able to move on.” 

Growing up Southern Baptist in small town Appalachia, Rollins learned early that a woman’s main role was controlling her body. Part of this was millennial diet culture, which encouraged calorie counting and constant exercise, but part of it was the evangelical purity culture she was exposed to in church and at school, which taught that women don’t feel the same sexual desire as men, making them the “gatekeepers” of morality. Purity culture has always been part of society, but it reached a fever pitch during Rollins’ youth in the 1990s and 2000s, due to the rising influence of organizations like the Institute of Basic Life Principles and Focus on the Family. In Famished, Rollins illustrates how these teachings influence everything from sexual agency to a woman’s ability to recognize when she is being preyed upon. 

Rollins and I spoke about the far-reaching implications of these teachings, including how purity culture impacts women’s sexuality, the racialization of fatphobia during Reconstruction, and why the most powerful critiques of fundamentalism often come from those who grew up within it.


Deirdre Sugiuchi: I’m Gen X, I grew up evangelical, and while reading Famished, it was fascinating to see millennial diet culture and millennial evangelism colliding, and how the consequences were even worse for you than for Gen X.

Anna Rollins: I’m a huge fan of Sophie Gilbert’s Girl on Girl, and she talks about how, in the nineties, the reaction to the AIDS crisis was this huge fear of sex. People swung one of two ways—it led to hookup culture, but then it also led to purity culture. 

At the same time, the surgeon general declared this war on obesity. So, there’s all this stuff going on politically that’s influencing how we feel about bodies and appetites, and there are extreme reactions on both sides. And then you’re growing up, trying to figure out how to become a woman in the middle of that. 

DS: The book is addressing women raised in evangelical culture, but how do you think this mindset impacts women in America?

AR: We see it in our lack of social safety nets for women, like with paid family leave. The reason we don’t have it is because of [fundamentalist] scripts about traditional womanhood and motherhood—how you are subordinate to a man and you should rely on that person—that is why we won’t fund this thing that would help so many people. It leaves people in such precarious states. Even if you’re not in purity culture, you’re being affected by it—things are not happening politically because of that belief system.

I’m interested in conversations where we can show up with authenticity.

There’s this idea in purity culture that if you are good, if you dress modestly, and you don’t hang out in the wrong spaces, you won’t be taken advantage of in any way. And if something does happen to you somehow, you must have done something wrong. It’s your fault. It’s never the perpetrator. It’s the victim. 

That affects the larger culture too, in the way that we see certain people believed and other people not believed. So even though it may seem like it’s just happening in this insular space, it’s affecting all of our lives through policy.

DS: You interrogate the misogynistic mindset of the church, albeit gently, throughout the book. You give these instances of how the church, and also society, wants women to stay small, by encouraging them to tamp down their sex drives, making sure they don’t lead men into sin, or by staying physically small or physically quiet. And again, as someone who grew up in this culture, this is all so familiar. How do you think women in the church will respond? What type of conversations would you hope that this would spark? 

AR: I grew up in fundamentalism, and it was extreme black and white thinking. We were supposed to have thought purity. We were all supposed to be the same. I’m interrogating these limiting scripts that require sameness. I’m hoping that we can talk about new ways forward for women that aren’t just extreme.

I had the hardest time expressing myself for the longest time because I always felt like there was some judge looking at my opinions, waiting to come down on me. In writing this, I realized, Oh, I can show up imperfectly in the world. I can change my mind. I don’t have to live under this belief that there’s always this ever watchful presence ready to pounce on any wrong move that I make. And I certainly learned that in the church, but I also see that in the larger culture too.

I think social media does a lot of that—we’re monitoring people’s beliefs and their purity of beliefs, and we don’t give much forgiveness for people whenever they stray or make a misstatement. I’m interested in conversations where we can show up with authenticity. But also imperfectly so we can have more agency.

DS: Even though I grew up in the faith, I never understood the tie between purity culture and penis-themed party favors for bachelorette parties until I read your book. 

AR: Growing up, I remember hearing pastors talk about how women were less visual creatures than men. And because of that we didn’t want sex as much. “Men really want it. They’re a bunch of animals, but you all are closer to angelic beings, so you all need to keep them in line.” 

You’re almost praised for not acknowledging what your body needs.

This was told as both a compliment, like you have the moral high ground, but it’s also an insult, because sex is power. 

Growing up I went to a private Christian school. I really didn’t have friends who weren’t Christian until I got to college. [My Christian friends and I] were all saving ourselves for marriage, whether everyone was or not—that was what we all said. But we also wanted to prove that we weren’t prudes, like, “We have this power too.”

All the bachelorette parties I went to with girls who grew up in evangelical culture, the trend was penis everything. We ordered a mold to bake a penis cake and we had penis confetti and pin the penis on the guy without a shirt on. It was stupid, but it was also just this assertion of saying “Yeah, we’ve got something too.” 

I didn’t realize how weird evangelical purity culture bachelorette parties are until I invited some of my friends who weren’t in that culture to my bachelorette party. 

DS: Can you discuss how the hyperfocus on purity has lifelong impacts on women’s sexuality?

AR: Many women suffer from vaginismus, which is sexual dysfunction. You have involuntary contractions of the pelvic floor, and it makes penetrative sex either impossible or incredibly painful. I struggled with it when I got married. I’d saved myself until marriage, and I had no clue what was going on. I’d been taught nothing about my body. I just assumed I was a total failure. I went to a doctor at one point and they dismissed me. Then finally I got some help and it got better, but it took an excruciatingly long time.

I did research on the condition, and women in religious cultures suffer from this double the number of women outside of those culture—one in four women.

You’ve been taught your whole life [sex] is bad. Control yourself and control these others. And then your body just learns, this is what we’re supposed to do

I can’t stay silent—this was my only way forward.

You’re almost praised for not acknowledging what your body needs. This is seen with the Protestant work ethic too—the more compulsive you are, the more you push past your physical limits, transcend your physical constraints—that is what is good. The body is bad. Having needs is bad. 

The political party that aligns itself with Christianity, so many of their positions demonizes people who have needs. I don’t think it’s something that people are consciously aware of, but I think it’s rooted in this idea that good people transcend their bodies. Good people work hard and good people control themselves. It’s all connected. 

DS: I really enjoyed the research you shared illustrating how fatphobia was racialized during Reconstruction.

AR: Thin bodies weren’t always the ideal beauty type [until] right around Reconstruction. It was a way for white, Victorian women to distinguish themselves, a way of asserting whiteness. And that has become the standard—this childlike, frail, prepubescent woman.

DS: You discuss how white supremacist patriarchy made white women smaller, but also gave white women power. I’ve read one book you mentioned, The Wisdom of Your Body by Hillary McBride. 

AR: Also Fearing the Black Body by Sabrina Strings. Unshrinking by Kate Manne is excellent—she’s a philosopher and she unpacks fatphobia, where it came from, how it influences our policies. Anti-fat bias is the one bias that’s grown rather than shrunk. 

I don’t know who said this, but when women’s rights shrink, women’s bodies shrink. I think it’s interesting that the backlash to body positivity is #skinnytok.

DS: Famished questions a lot of the tenets of fundamentalist culture. Can you talk about why there’s a need to have this conversation?

AR: I’m still a Christian, and I’m still in church. There’s a lot that I think is beautiful in the church . . . but I also can’t stay silent about the things that are harming people and are honestly against what Christianity has to say. I really do think that what I’m saying is not extreme or the minority opinion even in the church. More people need to speak out. I can’t stay silent—this was my only way forward. I think that Christianity has a lot of beauty—it has a lot to offer our culture and I don’t want to reject it. But so much that’s done in the name of Christianity really hurts people. It’s really ugly and it’s really anti-Christian. And if we don’t talk about that, it’s hurting the people that Jesus called upon us to help the most.

We Are Silent Skin Waiting to Sing

Red Fruit

Nobody ever begins from where it hurts. 
Overcome with ache, have we not lived

our lives thinking ourselves whole? Have we
not thought the echoes our hymn of being

complete? Look at the flowers. How they wait
patiently in the morning for the red sun.

Listen to their threnodies, all that yearning.
Because we have been nothing but bodies.

Nothing but wraps of skin waiting to be
filled with music—and every time we

kissed, another chorus unfurled. I was lost
to the symphony of our flesh and lips.

Because love greets a body soft like a finger
seeking only to open. Soft like flowers

warming to the red sun. And did we not
open? Did we not arise out of the earth

woundless and whole? We were slick, and
the world was newborn. O, we were alive.

And there were hearts beating in us.
In that night so white and verdant,

nothing mourned. Such sweet thing it is
to be complete. And so what? If we be

but lambs running through love's vast
fields, then let us run. I have tasted

the silence. I have tasted the song. I know
now what is worthy of being kept,

what is worthy of being lived through.
I know now the point where the music

begins to rain. Where we
begin to sing

Anti—

The night trudges on. A father teaches his
daughter, albeit feebly, to ride the bicycle.

Watch her dabble in her fields of joy. Full
of glee, her wounds still empty of knees.

At some point, the father gets on the bike,
and over the tarmac wings unfurl. His body

cutting into space—and she, stuck on Earth,
staring. The longing soaking us like hot water.

A longing so forlorn. Like how I have stared
at my life—this weak thing, aching for flight.

To escape the dark jungle of my country, my
birthland. I do not wish to be devoured. Do

not wish to be yet another sacrifice to another
abdominal god. At least the headlights held us

with mercy. All of that brilliance beholding
flesh. No wonder the deer see them as

salvation, even as their bodies greet the metal.
And are they wrong? What have we garnered

from all our years of living in the dark? What
have we gathered if not these bodies clawed

and torn? I do not wish to be devoured. Our
youth was not meant to be spent evading

wolves. Darling, I know you tire of my
lament. You hope that someday I would

write a poem about this country. Sing
of her beauty, praise her magnificence.

But are we not wounded? How much flattery
can unlatch from the prey the predator’s jaw?

We will tell ourselves these lies tomorrow. But
for now, sit, let us dwell on the blood staining

everywhere. Let us talk about our country,
and her ferocity. Her howls, her sharp teeth.